Sponsored Content
Top Forums UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users Comparing experience with AIX, HP-UX, and Solaris Post 302524553 by wenp on Monday 23rd of May 2011 07:24:38 PM
Old 05-23-2011
Comparing experience with AIX, HP-UX, and Solaris

I'm investigating AIX/HP-UX/Solaris for use in a research environment. Although there is plenty of technical documentation online, some important questions can only be answered from long user experience. I'd like to hear whatever you can contribute if you can compare at least two of these.

To get more specific, the proposed deployment is workstations for lab work. I suppose this case is quite different from server use. On the workstations, there will be no commercial software other than the OS; most of it will be data analysis tools written by subject specialists. Instead of setting up one machine to run unchanged for a long time, the workstations will have frequent changes of configuration by users of varying levels of skill.

I have four main areas of concern about which I'd like to hear your comparative evaluation of the three platforms:

1. Ease of building software developed on other *nix platforms.
Most of the tools we install would be only available as source code. So a major convenience factor will be how much effort is required to get things to build properly on a particular platform. I suppose the two main factors to consider are how "standard" the Unix flavor is and availability of debugging tools.

2. Stability against application crashing.
The workstations will be used for long computation and compilation jobs as well as productivity tasks. It is very important that a crashing app hangs nothing more than itself.

3. Convenience and stability of OS level virtualization
Virtualization is I suppose the strongest strategy for isolating a process. It should be quick to set up, be lightweight and stable, and completely prevent unwanted interaction with the host OS.

4. Ease of maintenance.
When things go wrong (buggy app, bad driver, stupid user, etc.), how much effort to pinpoint the problem and find/implement a fix? I'm thinking of the combined effects of opacity of the system, quality of documentation, community help, etc.

Any other points of comparison between AIX, HP-UX, and Solaris I'd be glad to hear also.

Cheers
 

8 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. Programming

How to get more experience???

I'm kinda fed up with all the theoretical side of the programming. now i'd love to participate in some project dealing with C network programming under Unix. My question is: is there any online programs or projects where i can really participate? Any other suggestions how to build up practical... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: solvman
1 Replies

2. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

How to get more experience???

Hi everybody, I'm kinda fed up with all the theoritical part of programming. I wonder if there is any online project or something where i can participate to practice my skills? Any other suggestions how to build up practical side of Unix C programming? Thank you all. (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: solvman
1 Replies

3. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Comparing AIX and Solaris

Is Solaris still very hardware dependent? As in it is used mostly on SUN workstations and servers? What about IBM's AIX? Does it only work on IBM machines? Which is more popular and are there performance or usage differences? (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: CapsuleCorpJX
1 Replies

4. Solaris

comparing 2 Solaris servers

hello has anyone built a script that compares 2 Solaris servers? CPU, memory, swap, memory variables in /etc/system, Solaris version Could you please advise on how to make such a comparaison? thanks (9 Replies)
Discussion started by: melanie_pfefer
9 Replies

5. AIX

Looking for AIX Practical Experience

I have been in IT for around 7 years now and have benefited greatly from Open Source as well as free commercial offerings like Vmware Server that allow me to setup virtual environments and get some hands on time with different OS's and software. I am starting a new job in a few weeks which has... (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: supercrazy1
5 Replies

6. AIX

Comparing two tar files on AIX

Hello, I have a directory which suddenly got filled up 100% from 70% ; (this is an oracle directory which has application and database in it ORACLE EBS) I do make cold backups, last month when I made cold backup of the directory /oratec the tar zip file was 31GB and this month when i made the... (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: filosophizer
5 Replies

7. Solaris

Experience sharing and questions for NIS migration from Solaris 8 to Linux

I'd like to share some experiences and what I found for NIS migration from Solaris 8 NIS to Linux platform. I'm not an expert for both platforms, it's just when I tested both systems and found something really tricky. That might takes a lot of time for you to find the root cause. So, I think I can... (11 Replies)
Discussion started by: bestard
11 Replies

8. UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers

Comparing time differences between 2 Solaris servers

Good day to all. I'm relatively new in using the Sun Solaris OS. I would like to request your expertise in helping to solve a problem that I have at work. Not sure if this has been asked before but I have tried searching through the internet to no avail. Basically I have 2 sun solaris... (8 Replies)
Discussion started by: Fossil_84
8 Replies
xVM(5)							Standards, Environments, and Macros						    xVM(5)

NAME
xVM, xvm - Solaris x86 virtual machine monitor DESCRIPTION
The Solaris xVM software (hereafter xVM) is a virtualization system, or virtual machine monitor, for the Solaris operating system on x86 systems. Solaris xVM enables you to run multiple virtual machines simultaneously on a single physical machine, often referred to as the host. Each virtual machine, known as a domain, runs its own complete and distinct operating system instance, which includes its own I/O devices. This differs from zone-based virtualization, in which all zones shares the same kernel. (See zones(5).) Each domain has a name and a UUID. Domains can be renamed but typically retain the same UUID. A domain ID is an integer that is specific to a running instance. It changes on every boot of the guest domain. Non-running domains do not have a domain ID. The xVM hypervisor is responsible for controlling and executing each of the domains and runs with full privileges. xVM also includes con- trol tools for management of the domains. These tools run under a specialized control domain, often referred to as domain 0. To run Solaris xVM, select the entry labelled Solaris xVM in the grub(5) menu at boot time. This boots the hypervisor, which in turn boots the control domain. The control domain is a version of Solaris modified to run under the xVM hypervisor. At the point at which the control domain is running, the control tools are enabled. In most other respects, the domain 0 instance behaves just like a "normal" instance of the Solaris operating system. The xVM hypervisor delegates control of the physical devices present on the machine to domain 0. Thus, by default, only domain 0 has access to such devices. The other guest domains running on the host are presented with virtualized devices with which they interact as they would physical devices. The xVM hypervisor schedules running domains (including domain 0) onto the set of physical CPUs as configured. The xVM scheduler is con- strained by domain configuration (the number of virtual CPUs allocated, and so forth) as well as any run-time configuration, such as pin- ning virtual CPUs to physical CPUs. The default domain scheduler in xVM is the credit scheduler. This is a work-conserving, fair-share domain scheduler; it balances virtual CPUs of domains across the allowed set of physical CPUs according to workload. xVM supports two modes of virtualization. In the first, the operating system is aware that it is running under xVM. This mode is called paravirtualization. In the second mode, called fully virtualized, the guest operating system is not aware that it is running under xVM. A fully virtualized guest domain is sometimes referred to as a Hardware-assisted Virtual Machine (HVM). A variation on a Hardware-assisted Virtual Machine is to use paravirtualized drivers for improved performance. This variation is abbreviated as HVM + PV. With paravirtualization, each device, such as a networking interface, is presented as a fully virtual interface, and specific drivers are required for it. Each virtual device is associated with a physical device and the driver is split into two. A frontend driver runs in the guest domain and communicates over a virtual data interface to a backend driver. The backend driver currently runs in domain 0 and communi- cates with both the frontend driver and the physical device underneath it. Thus, a guest domain can make use of a network card on the host, store data on a host disk drive, and so forth. Solaris xVM currently supports two main split drivers used for I/O. Networking is done by means of the xnb (xVM Networking Backend) driv- ers. Guest domains, whether Solaris or another operating system, use xnb to transmit and receive networking traffic. Typically, a physical NIC is used for communicating with the guest domains, either shared or dedicated. Solaris xVM provides networking access to guest domains by means of MAC-based virtual network switching. Block I/O is provided by the xdb (xVM Disk Backend) driver, which provides virtual disk access to guest domains. In the control domain, the disk storage can be in a file, a ZFS volume, or a physical device. Using ZFS volumes as the virtual disk for your guest domains allows you to take a snapshot of the storage. As such, you can keep known-good snapshots of the guest domain OS installation, and revert the snapshot (using zfs rollback) if the domain has a problem. The zfs clone com- mand can be used for quick provisioning of new domains. For example, you might install Solaris as a guest domain, run sys-unconfig(1M), then clone that disk image for use in new Solaris domains. Installing Solaris in this way requires only a configuration step, rather than a full install. When running as a guest domain, Solaris xVM uses the xnf and xdf drivers to talk to the relevant backend drivers. In addition to these drivers, the Solaris console is virtualized when running as a guest domain; this driver interacts with the xenconsoled(1M) daemon running in domain 0 to provide console access. A given system can have both paravirtualized and fully virtualized domains running simultaneously. The control domain must always run in paravirtualized mode, because it must work closely with the hypervisor layer. As guest domains do not share a kernel, xVM does not require that every guest domain be Solaris. For paravirtualized mode and for all types of operating systems, the only requirement is that the operating system be modified to support the virtual device interfaces. Fully-virtualized guest domains are supported under xVM with the assistance of virtualization extensions available on some x86 CPUs. These extensions must be present and enabled; some BIOS versions disable the extensions by default. In paravirtualized mode, Solaris identifies the platform as i86xpv, as seen in the return of the following uname(1) command: % uname -i i86xpv Generally, applications do not need to be aware of the platform type. It is recommended that any ISA identification required by an applica- tion use the -p option (for ISA or processor type) to uname, rather than the -i option, as shown above. On x86 platforms, regardless of whether Solaris is running under xVM, uname -p always returns i386. You can examine the domcaps driver to determine whether a Solaris instance is running as domain 0: # cat /dev/xen/domcaps control_d Note that the domcaps file might also contain additional information. However, the first token is always control_d when running as domain 0. xVM hosts provide a service management facility (SMF) service (see smf(5)) with the FMRI: svc:/system/xvm/domains:default ...to control auto-shutdown and auto-start of domains. By default, all running domains are shutdown when the host is brought down by means of init 6 or a similar command. This shutdown is analogous to entering: # virsh shutdown mydomain A domain can have the setting: on_xend_stop=ignore ...in which case the domain is not shut down even if the host is. Such a setting is the effective equivalent of: # virsh destroy mydomain If a domain has the setting: on_xend_start=start ...then the domain is automatically booted when the xVM host boots. Disabling the SMF service by means of svcadm(1M) disables this behavior for all domains. Solaris xVM is partly based on the work of the open source Xen community. Control Tools The control tools are the utilities shipped with Solaris xVM that enable you to manage xVM domains. These tools interact with the daemons that support xVM: xend(1M), xenconsoled(1M), and xenstored(1M), each described in its own man page. The daemons are, in turn, managed by the SMF. You install new guest domains with the command line virt-install(1M) or the graphical interface, virt-manager. The main interface for command and control of both xVM and guest domains is virsh(1M). Users should use virsh(1M) wherever possible, as it provides a generic and stable interface for controlling virtualized operating systems. However, some xVM operations are not yet implemented by virsh. In those cases, the legacy utility xm(1M) can be used for detailed control. The configuration of each domain is stored by xend(1M) after it has been created by means of virt-install, and can be viewed using the virsh dumpxml or xm list -l commands. Direct modification of this configuration data is not recommended; the command-line utility inter- faces should be used instead. Solaris xVM supports live migration of domains by means of the xm migrate command. This allows a guest domain to keep running while the host running the domain transfers ownership to another physical host over the network. The remote host must also be running xVM or a com- patible version of Xen, and must accept migration connections from the current host (see xend(1M)). For migration to work, both hosts must be able to access the storage used by the domU (for example, over iSCSI or NFS), and have enough resources available to run the migrated domain. Both hosts must currently reside on the same subnet for the guest domain networking to con- tinue working properly. Also, both hosts should have similar hardware. For example, migrating from a host with AMD processors to one with Intel processors can cause problems. Note that the communication channel for migration is not a secure connection. GLOSSARY
backend Describes the other half of a virtual driver from the frontend driver. The backend driver provides an interface between the virtual device and an underlying physical device. control domain The special guest domain running the control tools and given direct hardware access by the hypervisor. Often referred to as domain 0. domain 0 See control domain. frontend Describes a virtual device and its associated driver in a guest domain. A frontend driver communicates with a backend driver hosted in a different guest domain. full virtualization Running an unmodified operating system with hardware assistance. guest domain A virtual machine instance running on a host. Unless the guest is domain 0, such a domain is also called a domain-U, where U stands for "unprivileged". host The physical machine running xVM. Hardware-assisted Virtual Machine (HVM) A fully-virtualized guest domain. node The name used by the virsh(1M) utility for a host. virtual machine monitor (VMM) Hypervisor software, such as xVM, that manages multiple domains. SEE ALSO
uname(1), dladm(1M), svcadm(1M), sys-unconfig(1M), virsh(1M), virt-install(1M), xend(1M), xenconsoled(1M), xenstored(1M), xm(1M), zfs(1M), attributes(5), grub(5), live_upgrade(5), smf(5), zones(5) NOTES
Any physical Ethernet datalink (as shown by dladm show-phys) can be used to network guest domains. SunOS 5.11 14 Jan 2009 xVM(5)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:57 AM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy