bash shell: 'exec', 'eval', 'source' - looking for help to understand

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Top Forums Shell Programming and Scripting bash shell: 'exec', 'eval', 'source' - looking for help to understand
# 1  
Old 02-22-2008
bash shell: 'exec', 'eval', 'source' - looking for help to understand

Hi, experts.
Whould anybody clear explay me difference and usage of these 3 commands (particulary in bash) :

I've tryed to read the manual pages but did not get much.
Also could not get something useful from Google search - just so much and so not exactly, that is is not usefull
Would it be any different result in environment after using any of these command?
Where and for what purpose each should be used?
How and is there any difference to use those from interactive shell or from script?

Greately appreciate your help
# 2  
Old 02-22-2008
eval "translates" a value buried inside a variable, and then runs the command that was buried in there
for i in 1 2 3
   eval myvar="$i"
   echo "$myvar"
# this gives 
# why? because there is no metavalue or special meaning to 1 or 2 or 3

for i in ls df
    eval myvar="$i"
    echo "$myvar"
# here you get output from the ls command and the df command

exec starts another process - BUT - it exits the current process when you do this kind of thing


exec echo "leaving this script forever  $0"   # Exit from script here.

# ----------------------------------
# The following line never happens

echo "This echo will never echo."


When you run a command in the shell - like another script or a command like ls -
the shell creates a subprocess (called child process). Any environment variable that got defined or changed down in the child is LOST FOREVER to the parent process.

However if you source a script (there are two ways) you force the script to run in the current process. That means environment variables in the script you ran are NOT LOST.

# script1
MYVAR="HI there!"
# end script1

# script2
# first, run script 1
# now is the MYVAR variable set?  No -why? it got set in the child, when the child exited it GOT LOST
echo "MYVAR= $MYVAR"
# now source script1 :: putting a lonesome dot or the command  "source" 
#  in front of the script name have the same effect
. script1
#  . script1 == source script1  these two are the SAME THING
source script1
# now is the MYVAR variable set?  This time we see that MYVAR has a value
echo "MYVAR= $MYVAR"

This User Gave Thanks to jim mcnamara For This Post:
# 3  
Old 02-22-2008
jim mcnamara -
thank you, very much, everything clear and usefull for me now!

I am realy exiting to understand it. Now I have new (for me ) possibility in scripting and in shell.
Definetely, 'eval' gives usefull opportunity!
The 'exec' - nice to know that and it is good to use it, too.
The 'sorce' - it appeared that I have used it already for long time (as '. script') but did not realized tha all definishions of the curent shell are available in runing script by that (other part - backward - usualy is a reason to use the '. scr')
I've just tryed it and maybe it would be usefull to show it here, too, although your explanation pretty enough, but, anyway, here it is:

bash-802:/home/dca0701/develop/src> cat >
/usr/bin/echo "\n -- try to use already defined in shell alias:"
ec "<<< this printed by shell alias 'ec'"

shopt -s expand_aliases
alias ec2=ec
ec "--- new alias is declared as ec2"
bash-803:/home/dca0701/develop/src> chmod 777

 -- try to use already defined in shell alias:
./ ec: command not found
./ ec: command not found
bash-805:/home/dca0701/develop/src> source

 -- try to use already defined in shell alias:
<<< this printed by shell alias 'ec'
--- new alias is declared as ec2
bash-806:/home/dca0701/develop/src> ec2 hello

Once again, thank you very much!
# 4  
Old 07-24-2008
One thing that eval does that is critical is break things apart in strings. For example if in a script you wrote lscommand="ls -F", then tried to run $lscommand, the shell would give you an amusing error that it didn't find the command ls -F. If instead you eval $lscommand, it works fine. One place I use that a lot is in a script where some args are to be passed to a command (or commands). I gather them together in variable, such as lsoptions="$lsoptions $arg" At the end of dealing with the arguments, the lsoptions might have for example, "-F -a". If I try to run ls $lsoptions ls will complain about the argument "-F -a" (and you'll get really odd incomprehensible complaints too! If instead, I do eval ls $lsoptions it does just what I wanted. Yea!

Login or Register to Ask a Question

Previous Thread | Next Thread

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. Shell Programming and Scripting

How to understand special character for line reading in bash shell?

I am still learning shell scripting. Recently I see a function for read configuration. But some of special character make me confused. I checked online to find answer. It was not successful. I post the code here to consult with expert or guru to get better understanding on these special characters... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: duke0001
3 Replies

2. Shell Programming and Scripting

Shell Script Comment code blocks in a bash source file

Just began to learn on Shell Script. I got an exercise from my friend. I know how to make this happen in C, but I'm not familiar with Shell Script. Hope I can get some help from all of you. I want to write a bash script to comment code blocks in a bash source file. What I mean comment is '#', I... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: HiFuture0801
1 Replies

3. Programming

Help me to understand strange 'typedef ... ' in some source...

Working on some source I've found some strange declaration in included header file. I am looking for someone's help to understand me that syntax's, as it is fine (it is compiled without any complain,) but for me it seems out of any sense! Acctually, it warning by CC compiler: " Warning: Implicit... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: alex_5161
1 Replies

4. Shell Programming and Scripting

Not able to understand use exec command

Hi i am in learning phase of unix. i was going through exec in a unix book. below is the command exec n>file exec n>>file however when i used the exec command like below , where ex is the file name exec 2>>exand then do ls -lrt then again when i do the ls -lrt to see the size of the file... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: scriptor
3 Replies

5. Programming

Need help with this c++ source code! DOnt understand what some stuff mean.

Okay so I am just starting programming c++. I just started started to red "C++ for Dummies yesterday and theres a lot of things I do not understand from this book and this source code especially. I will first post the full source code and then post questions about certain thing, usually what they... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: orszhak
2 Replies

6. Shell Programming and Scripting

I need to understand the differences between the bash shell and the Bourne shell

I do not claim to be an expert, but I have done things with scripts that whole teams of folks have said can not be done. Of course they should have said we do not have the intestinal fortitude to git-r-done. I have been using UNIX actually HPUX since 1992. Unfortunately my old computer died and... (7 Replies)
Discussion started by: awk_sed_hello
7 Replies

7. Programming

help me understand exec() family of calls...

how does exec() do it? on successful call of exec() family of functions, they never return... how to i emulate that. assume the standard example, execl("/bin/ls","ls",NULL); now this would never return. i m trying to emulate exec()'s never to return feature... #include<unistd.h>... (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: c_d
4 Replies

8. Shell Programming and Scripting

Exec bash shell via PHP Site !

Hi everybody ! I writed php code so exec bash shell via php (SMS Send via bash shell) but i have problem as follow : 1. When i exec from linux mode : ./ --- output is "Messages ... OK". Then all message has been sent. 2. When i exec from PHP site --- return value is "Message ... OK" on... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: lamthenhan
1 Replies

9. Shell Programming and Scripting

exit status of eval exec

I am using ksh88 and I am trying to catch the return status of opening a file using a file descriptor and the exec and eval commands. However I am not having much success. Here is what I have: eval "exec $next_fh>$1" This opens the file if the file is $1 is valid, however I want to make... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: robotball
1 Replies

10. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

difference between source, exec and ./script

What is the difference between sourcing a script, running it or execing it? (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: 98_1LE
1 Replies
Login or Register to Ask a Question