Sponsored Content
Full Discussion: semaphore access speed
Top Forums Programming semaphore access speed Post 302243827 by migurus on Monday 6th of October 2008 03:54:40 PM
Old 10-06-2008
Otheus, I never dealt with reporting on bugzilla, it seems ti me I don't quite qualify and I'm afraid I will post something not pertinent, so if you would agree to do it yourself, here are the results from 2nd version of your 'gettimeofday-based' code, which I re-run 4 times as to get average:

SCO
$ tmx2
575108.94 semop/s (5000000/8694005)
$ tmx2
575215.00 semop/s (5000000/8692402)
$ tmx2
575183.63 semop/s (5000000/8692876)
$ tmx2
559832.49 semop/s (5000000/8931243)

Linux:
$ ./tmx2
129363.77 semop/s (5000000/38650699)
$ ./tmx2
129428.22 semop/s (5000000/38631452)
$ ./tmx2
129601.55 semop/s (5000000/38579786)
$ ./tmx2
129511.76 semop/s (5000000/38606534)


As you see, no difference from the former tests.

Just for my clarification: somehow people who participated in this discussion on unix.com formu as well as on kerneltrap and other places were very concerned with 2 things, that in my perspective are irrelevant to the subject of this thread: time measurement accuracy and involvement of running multiple processes/shells etc that would muddy the results. I would wholeheartedly agree to that IF SCO vs Linux results were comparable. But this is not the case here. SCO is three times faster, no matter we used my method or gettimeofday very accurate method. With all the overhead being roughly similar, I would think we were kind of beating around the bush when we were trying to achieve have accuracy in measurement (which does not hurt, of cource!), but it made the thread bloated.

Again, thanks to Otheus for your suggestions, at this point I the kernel code you pinpoint shows that multi-cpu capability adds a layer of complexity and it does not help the speed. Your and strcmp's (kerneltrap forum) recomendations to upgrade Linux kernel are well taken.
migurus
 

9 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

semaphore

hi, is there any command where we can monitor semaphores? (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: yls177
1 Replies

2. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Semaphore

Hi, I'm new to UNIX. I need to know what's a semaphore Do reply. Thanks VJ (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: vjsony
3 Replies

3. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

dmidecode, RAM speed = "Current Speed: Unknown"

Hello, I have a Supermicro server with a P4SCI mother board running Debian Sarge 3.1. This is the "dmidecode" output related to RAM info: RAM speed information is incomplete.. "Current Speed: Unknown", is there anyway/soft to get the speed of installed RAM modules? thanks!! Regards :)... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: Santi
0 Replies

4. Shell Programming and Scripting

Semaphore

Hi, I am looking to use a semaphore for the first time in one of my scripts. I am just wondering if there are any simple examples or tutorials around? I am a beginner so the simpler the better :) Thanks -Jaken (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: Jaken
2 Replies

5. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

semaphore

what is semaphore? can any body explain it in a more simple way than the manual ?? replies appreciated Regards raguram R (7 Replies)
Discussion started by: raguramtgr
7 Replies

6. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

data from blktrace: read speed V.S. write speed

I analysed disk performance with blktrace and get some data: read: 8,3 4 2141 2.882115217 3342 Q R 195732187 + 32 8,3 4 2142 2.882116411 3342 G R 195732187 + 32 8,3 4 2144 2.882117647 3342 I R 195732187 + 32 8,3 4 2145 ... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: W.C.C
1 Replies

7. Shell Programming and Scripting

semaphore

Control two exclusively shared resources(semaphore). The two resources are two files. The producer will write even numbers to one file, and odd numbers to another one. The consumer respectively reads from each file until it gets 5 even numbers and 5 odd numbers. Can any one help me with the... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: gokult
0 Replies

8. Programming

Semaphore

If I create a semaphore and then I fork a number of child processes then all the child process use that same semaphore. Since the process address spaces are different rfom each other then how all the child process are able to access the same semaphore? I understand that semaphore/mutex is at os... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: rupeshkp728
0 Replies

9. UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers

Semaphore

I was asked to add this piece of code to a c program which I will execute through the shell: for(long i = 0; i < NITER; i++) { sem_wait( &sema); count++; sem_post( &sema); } I didn't get it, which is the critical section ? if it's "count++" how would a thread wake up in order to enter it... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: uniran
1 Replies
semop(2)							   System Calls 							  semop(2)

NAME
semop, semtimedop - semaphore operations SYNOPSIS
#include <sys/types.h> #include <sys/ipc.h> #include <sys/sem.h> int semop(int semid, struct sembuf *sops, size_t nsops); int semtimedop(int semid, struct sembuf *sops, size_t nsops, const struct timespec *timeout); DESCRIPTION
The semop() function is used to perform atomically an array of semaphore operations on the set of semaphores associated with the semaphore identifier specified by semid. The sops argument is a pointer to the array of semaphore-operation structures. The nsops argument is the number of such structures in the array. Each sembuf structure contains the following members: short sem_num; /* semaphore number */ short sem_op; /* semaphore operation */ short sem_flg; /* operation flags */ Each semaphore operation specified by sem_op is performed on the corresponding semaphore specified by semid and sem_num. The permission required for a semaphore operation is given as {token}, where token is the type of permission needed. The types of permission are inter- preted as follows: 00400 READ by user 00200 ALTER by user 00040 READ by group 00020 ALTER by group 00004 READ by others 00002 ALTER by others See the Semaphore Operation Permissions section of intro(2) for more information. A process maintains a value, semadj, for each semaphore it modifies. This value contains the cumulative effect of operations the process has performed on an individual semaphore with the SEM_UNDO flag set (so that they can be undone if the process terminates unexpectedly). The value of semadj can affect the behavior of calls to semop(), semtimedop(), exit(), and _exit() (the latter two functions documented on exit(2)), but is otherwise unobservable. See below for details. The sem_op member specifies one of three semaphore operations: 1. The sem_op member is a negative integer; {ALTER} o If semval (see intro(2)) is greater than or equal to the absolute value of sem_op, the absolute value of sem_op is subtracted from semval. Also, if (sem_flg&SEM_UNDO) is true, the absolute value of sem_op is added to the calling process's semadj value (see exit(2)) for the specified semaphore. o If semval is less than the absolute value of sem_op and (sem_flg&IPC_NOWAIT) is true, semop() returns immediately. o If semval is less than the absolute value of sem_op and (sem_flg&IPC_NOWAIT) is false, semop() increments the semncnt associated with the specified semaphore and suspends execution of the calling thread until one of the following conditions occur: o The value of semval becomes greater than or equal to the absolute value of sem_op. When this occurs, the value of semncnt associated with the specified semaphore is decremented, the absolute value of sem_op is subtracted from semval and, if (sem_flg&SEM_UNDO) is true, the absolute value of sem_op is added to the calling process's semadj value for the specified semaphore. o The semid for which the calling thread is awaiting action is removed from the system (see semctl(2)). When this occurs, errno is set to EIDRM and -1 is returned. o The calling thread receives a signal that is to be caught. When this occurs, the value of semncnt associated with the speci- fied semaphore is decremented, and the calling thread resumes execution in the manner prescribed in sigaction(2). 2. The sem_op member is a positive integer; {ALTER} The value of sem_op is added to semval and, if (sem_flg&SEM_UNDO) is true, the value of sem_op is subtracted from the calling process's semadj value for the specified semaphore. 3. The sem_op member is 0; {READ} o If semval is 0, semop() returns immediately. o If semval is not equal to 0 and (sem_flg&IPC_NOWAIT) is true, semop() returns immediately. o If semval is not equal to 0 and (sem_flg&IPC_NOWAIT) is false, semop() increments the semzcnt associated with the specified sema- phore and suspends execution of the calling thread until one of the following occurs: o The value of semval becomes 0, at which time the value of semzcnt associated with the specified semaphore is set to 0 and all processes waiting on semval to become 0 are awakened. o The semid for which the calling thread is awaiting action is removed from the system. When this occurs, errno is set to EIDRM and -1 is returned. o The calling thread receives a signal that is to be caught. When this occurs, the value of semzcnt associated with the speci- fied semaphore is decremented, and the calling thread resumes execution in the manner prescribed in sigaction(2). Upon successful completion, the value of sempid for each semaphore specified in the array pointed to by sops is set to the process ID of the calling process. The semtimedop() function behaves as semop() except when it must suspend execution of the calling process to complete its operation. If semtimedop() must suspend the calling process after the time interval specified in timeout expires, or if the timeout expires while the process is suspended, semtimedop() returns with an error. If the timespec structure pointed to by timeout is zero-valued and semtimedop() needs to suspend the calling process to complete the requested operation(s), it returns immediately with an error. If timeout is the NULL pointer, the behavior of semtimedop() is identical to that of semop(). RETURN VALUES
Upon successful completion, 0 is returned. Otherwise, -1 is returned and errno is set to indicate the error. ERRORS
The semop() and semtimedop() functions will fail if: E2BIG The nsops argument is greater than the system-imposed maximum. See NOTES. EACCES Operation permission is denied to the calling process (see intro(2)). EAGAIN The operation would result in suspension of the calling process but (sem_flg&IPC_NOWAIT) is true. EFAULT The sops argument points to an illegal address. EFBIG The value of sem_num is less than 0 or greater than or equal to the number of semaphores in the set associated with semid. EIDRM A semid was removed from the system. EINTR A signal was received. EINVAL The semid argument is not a valid semaphore identifier, or the number of individual semaphores for which the calling process requests a SEM_UNDO would exceed the limit. ENOSPC The limit on the number of individual processes requesting an SEM_UNDO would be exceeded. ERANGE An operation would cause a semval or a semadj value to overflow the system-imposed limit. The semtimedop() function will fail if: EAGAIN The timeout expired before the requested operation could be completed. The semtimedop() function will fail if one of the following is detected: EFAULT The timeout argument points to an illegal address. EINVAL The timeout argument specified a tv_sec or tv_nsec value less than 0, or a tv_nsec value greater than or equal to 1000 mil- lion. ATTRIBUTES
See attributes(5) for descriptions of the following attributes: +-----------------------------+-----------------------------+ | ATTRIBUTE TYPE | ATTRIBUTE VALUE | +-----------------------------+-----------------------------+ |Interface Stability |semop() is Standard. | +-----------------------------+-----------------------------+ SEE ALSO
ipcs(1), rctladm(1M), intro(2), exec(2), exit(2), fork(2), semctl(2), semget(2), setrctl(2), sigaction(2), attributes(5), standards(5) NOTES
The system-imposed maximum on nsops for a semaphore identifier is the minimum enforced value of the process.max-sem-ops resource control of the creating process at the time semget(2) was used to allocate the identifier. See rctladm(1M) and setrctl(2) for information about using resource controls. SunOS 5.10 13 May 2003 semop(2)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:34 AM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy