UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

From 1983 to 1987, Bell Labs researcher Jon Bentley wrote an interesting column in Communications of the ACM titled Programming Pearls. Some of the columns were later collected, with substantial changes, into two books listed in the Chapter 16. In one of the columns, Bentley posed this challenge: write a program to process a text file, and output a list of the n most-frequent words, with counts of their frequency of occurrence, sorted by descending count. Noted computer scientists Donald Knuth and David Hanson responded separately with interesting and clever literate programs,[7] each of which took several hours to write. Bentley's original specification was imprecise, so Hanson rephrased it this way: Given a text file and an integer n, you are to print the words (and their frequencies of occurrence) whose frequencies of occurrence are among the n largest in order of decreasing frequency.

[7] Programming Pearls: A Literate Program: A WEB program for common words, Comm. ACM 29(6), 471-483, June (1986), and Programming Pearls: Literate Programming: Printing Common Words, 30(7), 594-599, July (1987). Knuth's paper is also reprinted in his book Literate Programming, Stanford University Center for the Study of Language and Information, 1992, ISBN 0-937073-80-6 (paper) and 0-937073-81-4 (cloth).

In the first of Bentley's articles, fellow Bell Labs researcher Doug McIlroy reviewed Knuth's program, and offered a six-step Unix solution that took only a couple of minutes to develop and worked correctly the first time. Moreover, unlike the two other programs, McIlroy's is devoid of explicit magic constants that limit the word lengths, the number of unique words, and the input file size. Also, its notion of what constitutes a word is defined entirely by simple patterns given in its first two executable statements, making changes to the word-recognition algorithm easy.

McIlroy's program illustrates the power of the Unix tools approach: break a complex problem into simpler parts that you already know how to handle. To solve the word-frequency problem, McIlroy converted the text file to a list of words, one per line (tr does the job), mapped words to a single lettercase (tr again), sorted the list (sort), reduced it to a list of unique words with counts (uniq), sorted that list by descending counts (sort), and finally, printed the first several entries in the list (sed, though head would work too).

The resulting program is worth being given a name (wf, for word frequency) and wrapped in a shell script with a comment header. We also extend McIlroy's original sed command to make the output list-length argument optional, and we modernize the sort options. We show the complete program in Example 5-5.