This is what I have done so far:
So here is the problems that I am facing now:
1. How do I stop this? I mean how can I make ./reminder -k stop to work? I thought about writing the pid of the parent to file and then using it to stop the program.
2. How can put the parent to background so that I get my stdin back at prompt? Now what happens is that the parent keeps waiting for the child to end, which never happens. What I did was I just removed the wait(&status) and replace it with return 0;. So now the parent will exit and the child will keep on popping up the reminder texts.
The way you're using strcpy is incorrect. Neither char *script nor char *text point to properly allocated memory. Instead, they are uninitialized and pointing to arbitrary locations. You may get lucky, or you may segfault.
char *content points to 1000 bytes, but the code does not prevent a long reminder from overflowing the buffer. In this case, you could get the job done with a single fprintf. Why construct a string in a buffer when you can write the text directly to the stream?
Using atoi in new code is asking for trouble, since it does not perform any type of error checking.
The -k start|stop switch is redundant with the presence of -t. You can set all of the appropriate (int) flags based on the presence or absence of -t.
I did not try to compile the program. I only skimmed the code. There may be other issues lurking. If you haven't done so, enable all of your compilers warnings.
The way you're using strcpy is incorrect. Neither char *script nor char *text point to properly allocated memory. Instead, they are uninitialized and pointing to arbitrary locations. You may get lucky, or you may segfault.
So I need to use malloc first and then do the assign operation. I made the following changes :
and
Quote:
Originally Posted by alister
char *content points to 1000 bytes, but the code does not prevent a long reminder from overflowing the buffer. In this case, you could get the job done with a single fprintf. Why construct a string in a buffer when you can write the text directly to the stream?
Ok so I will include a check for the size of the text entered by the user and then if its larger than the allowed limit, I will set it to a default value.
Quote:
Originally Posted by alister
Using atoi in new code is asking for trouble, since it does not perform any type of error checking.
Include a validation for this as well.
Quote:
Originally Posted by alister
The -k start|stop switch is redundant with the presence of -t. You can set all of the appropriate (int) flags based on the presence or absence of -t.
Actually I have made only the -k start/stop option mandatory. The other two are optional. So if the user do not give them, both the reminder text and the countdown will be set to a default value.
Quote:
Originally Posted by alister
I did not try to compile the program. I only skimmed the code. There may be other issues lurking. If you haven't done so, enable all of your compilers warnings.
I enabled all the warnings and I got the below output:
For the first warning I did a type casting to int.
and for the second one I included the sys/wait.h
But still my question remains. How do i make the program stop?
Now I am doing Ctrl-C from the prompt to end the program.
How can I make it stop when I enter ./reminder -k stop
Thanks
---------- Post updated at 06:33 AM ---------- Previous update was at 05:00 AM ----------
So I have made the changes and this is a working copy. And I found an interesting feature. If I give the reminder text as ';rm a;echo ', the file a actually gets removed. So I can give anything between the semi-colon and the script will execute it. Interesting...
As before, I did not compile or test the code. There may be other issues.
content is allocated and freed but never used.
fd will never contain an error code; it's always a pointer value. When that pointer is NULL, it indicates an error and the error code is in errno. That's what you should be inspecting during error handling. To convert the integer errno into a useful message, something like strerror() will help.
As you discovered, inserting arbitrary text into a script can present serious issues. The simplest solution is to write the reminder's text to a separate file.
strcpy of optarg to text is unsafe and can overflow. You can use strncpy, but then must be careful to ensure that the string is always null-terminated. strlcpy is a simpler alternative, if available. However, the simplest alternative in this case is to not copy at all.
Not only do you not need to copy, you don't need to allocate either. The reminder's text has already been allocated storage during startup. It's in argv. The only thing you need to do is pass around the pointer. The default value has also been stored away in the executable's image and it's location can also be passed around.
You implied that you are no longer waiting in the parent, but since the code is still there, a couple of notes about it.
You should always check WIFEXITED before using WEXITSTATUS (as you did with WIFSIGNALED before using WTERMSIG). An implementation is not forbidden from overloading bits for signal and status information (though I don't know if any implementation actually does so).
For portability and readability (especially for readability), it's a far better choice to use the macros in signal.h. Instead of 6, use SIGABRT. As far as I know, even though the kill(1) utility is required to recognize -6 as SIGABRT, nothing requires the kill(2) system call implementation to equate 6 with SIGABRT (although it almost certainly does).
Regarding your interprocess communication question, your pid file idea seems perfectly reasonable.
To answer 2, to put the process in background, you will have to
1. fork from the parent.
2. terminate the parent so the child is owned by init.
3. and dissociate the tty by setting session (setsid)
So at this point using the pid file, sounds like a good solution to stop it, since the parent process is dead.
This User Gave Thanks to linuxpenguin For This Post:
I have tried to fix as many as issues I can that has been pointed out by @alister. In this version of the reminder program the parent will exit after fork. The pid of the child that calls the xterm is written into a file which is used to kill the child when needed. And the best thing I got no warnings!! Happly with that
Now I will try and implement the second approach in which I put the process in background and try to kill the child using it. i have no idea how I am going to do that. First off I will just try to make the parent a background process. Will figure out the rest along the way.
hi
I want to call a lot of links with the post method
What to do to speed it up??
####This method is slow
#!/bin/bash
func2() {
index1=0
while read line ; do
index1=$(($index1+1))
url=$line
done < tmp/url1.txt
} (10 Replies)
I am trying to write a large X app. I have successfully modified my xorg.conf to setup 4 monitors on an NVIDIA Quatro5200. I am trying to modify a simple hello world application to open a window on three of the four monitors. depending on the changes to loop the window creation section and event... (2 Replies)
Hi,
I have a problem where I need to make this input:
nameRow1a,text1a,text2a,floatValue1a,FloatValue2a,...,floatValue140a
nameRow1b,text1b,text2b,floatValue1b,FloatValue2b,...,floatValue140b
look like this output:
nameRow1a,text1b,text2a,(floatValue1a - floatValue1b),(floatValue2a -... (4 Replies)
I have a unix directory where a million of small text files getting accumulated every week.
As of now there is a shell batch program in place which merges all the files in this directory into a single file and ftp to other system.
Previously the volume of the files would be around 1 lakh... (2 Replies)
I read that 'Any single program that can run as multiple processes can benefit from OpenMosix: "The GIMP" photo editor and the "kandel" fractal generator are known to do this.
Are there other load-balancing clusters that do support multi-process applications? (1 Reply)
Hi,
I'm trying to compile the following code:
/************** Begin <test.c> ***************/
/*
* Compiled with: gcc -Wall -o test test.c
*/
#include <stdio.h>
#include <unistd.h>
int main(void)
{
printf("I'm process %d, son of %d \n", getpid(), getppid());
... (5 Replies)
Hi,
I'm trying to compile the following code:
/************** Begin <test.c> ***************/
/*
* Compiled with: gcc -Wall -o test test.c
*/
#include <stdio.h>
#include <unistd.h>
int main(void)
{
printf("I'm process %d, son of %d \n", getpid(), getppid());
printf("Hello \n");... (3 Replies)
Hi,
Am supposed to use message queues to send and receive messages between the processes. when i was working on that i realised that the message qid and the message queue related data should be maintained in a shared memory so that it can be accessed by all the processes. Could anybody refer... (10 Replies)
Dear Experts
Why we always hear that unix operating system is Multi User and Multi task. What does these two means. I have looked at some books and documents but couldn't find aclear explenation. Can we say Windows operating system is also multi user and multi task??
Thanks for your help in... (6 Replies)
If I want to write program that spread the work to its child process so that each process compute some task what should I do?
The objective of my program is to fill in the table which (10*10) in dimension and each column is filled with the fibonacci value of i+j (i mean current row and j mean... (1 Reply)