Sponsored Content
Special Forums Hardware Filesystems, Disks and Memory ReiserFS vs ext3 vs anything else? Post 85083 by Perderabo on Friday 30th of September 2005 05:26:02 PM
Old 09-30-2005
Heh.. dangerous thread here... According to our rules:
(8) No BSD vs. Linux vs. Windows or similar threads.
and really that is what this will ultimately come down to. Some discussion is possible, but after that we may close the thread.

ext2 is clearly not ready for prime time. Without journalling, a filesystem can't really compete today. ReiserFS offered journalling first and some distros switched to it. Other stuff was large file and volume support. ext3 finally came out and possibly surpassed ReiserFS. Between ReiserFS and ext3 reasonable minds can disagree. Development is continuing on both. Both have supporters who make various claims. Making ReiserFS a default is a way for one Linux distro to distinguish itself all the others. Considering that they all run the Linux kernel with GNU utilities, thats not real easy to do. And you can't flip-flop back and forth without alienating everyone.

Perhaps neither will "win" and ReiserFS/ext3 will join HP-UX/SunOS and Suse/Redhat and all the other muliple choices we have. It seems a little wasteful, but the competition is actually very healthy.

Sun did some benchmarking... see: this paper (PDF file).
 

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

Convert filesystem from reiserfs to ext2

Hi, My current linux server's filesystems is reiserfs. Unfortunately I need to enable quota for my users and as far as I know quota won't run on reiserfs. So, can I convert the filesystem types to ext2 from reiserfs without having to re-install my o/s? Or, is there any quota applications... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: vancouver_joe
1 Replies

2. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Anyone else see a performance hit from ext3

I reinstalled my Linux box with RedHat 7.2 and used the ext3 journaling file system. This thing is a pig now. There isn't much running on the box, and performance is sad. (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: 98_1LE
1 Replies

3. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

ext3 filesystem

what do you think about the ext3 journal filesystem?? (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: comadreja
3 Replies

4. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

Grub and Reiserfs

Hi all I just installed Fedora Core 3 onto my pc which is running slackware as the 'main' os I have been using LILO as the boot loader for a long time but thought I'd swap to GRUB for a change. Fedora boots fine. I have a seperate /boot partition for my slackware install ......its... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: silvaman
0 Replies

5. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

EXT3 Performance tuning

Hi all, long time ago I posted something, but now, it is needed again :( Currently, I am handling with a big NFS Server for more than 200 clients, this sever has to work with 256 NFSDs. Because of this huge amount of NFSDs, there are thousands of small write accesses down to the disk and... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: malcom
3 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

/ext2 and /ext3

Hi all, I was installing linux, so i want to know the basic difference between /ext2 and /ext3 filetype.. what is the significance of using /ext2 and /ext3 pls clarify Thanks Vasikaran (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: vasikaran
2 Replies

7. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

root directory with reiserfs??

Today,I have recompile kernel 2.6.24 with reiserfs support with Module on rhel5.then I make following change: 1:change /etc/fstab: /dev/Vg1/lv.root / reiserfs defaults 1 1 and cd /boot/; mkinitrd --with=reiserfs initrd-reiserfs-2.6.24.img. 2.6.24 2:then I use other support... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: hshzh359
0 Replies

8. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Mounting fs ext3

I'm trying to find a correct command that will mount a filesystem ext3 the device /dev/sda1 to mount point /mnt/usb but not allow any programs to run from it. I want to be honest as I've read the forum rules... This is a homework question BUT, i'm generally interested in the correct process and... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: CasperQuiet
3 Replies

9. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Question regarding mkfs ext3

Hi i am looking for some help with a question relating to the creation of the ext3 file system. "Why is it good practice not to have a file system mounted whilst you try to create it?" I have searched google but not had any luck in finding out what the actual dangers are of creating a file... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: allan1986
1 Replies

10. Linux

Mount reiserfs .dsk image failed: can't read superblock

I have a failed 160 GB Western Digital Netcenter NAS disk and its image after failing in .DSK format. When I connect the disk to my ubuntu machine and typed: # losetup -o 512006144 /dev/loop1 /dev/sdc # mkdir /tmp/sdc # mount -r -t reiserfs /dev/loop1 /tmp/sdc I get my folders and... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: jalil1408
0 Replies
MKREISERFS(8)						      System Manager's Manual						     MKREISERFS(8)

NAME
mkreiserfs - The create tool for the Linux ReiserFS filesystem. SYNOPSIS
mkreiserfs [ -dfV ] [ -b | --block-size N ] [ -h | --hash HASH ] [ -u | --uuid UUID ] [ -l | --label LABEL ] [ --format FORMAT ] [ -q | --quiet ] [ -j | --journal-device FILE ] [ -s | --journal-size N ] [ -o | --journal-offset N ] [ -t | --transaction-max-size N ] [ -B | --badblocks file ] device [ filesystem-size ] DESCRIPTION
mkreiserfs creates a Linux ReiserFS filesystem on a device (usually a disk partition). device is the special file corresponding to a device or to a partition (e.g /dev/hdXX for an IDE disk partition or /dev/sdXX for a SCSI disk partition). filesystem-size is the size in blocks of the filesystem. If omitted, mkreiserfs will automatically set it. OPTIONS
-b | --block-size N N is block size in bytes. It may only be set to a power of 2 within the 512-8192 interval. -h | --hash HASH HASH specifies which hash function will sort the names in the directories. Choose from r5, rupasov, or tea. r5 is the default one. --format FORMAT FORMAT specifies the format for the new filsystem. Choose format 3.5 or 3.6. If none is specified mkreiserfs will create format 3.6 if running kernel is 2.4 or higher, and format 3.5 if kernel 2.2 is running, and will refuse creation under all other kernels. -u | --uuid UUID Sets the Universally Unique IDentifier of the filesystem to UUID (see also uuidgen(8)). The format of the UUID is a series of hex digits separated by hypthens, e.g.: "c1b9d5a2-f162-11cf-9ece-0020afc76f16". If the option is skipped, mkreis- erfs will by default generate a new UUID. -l | --label LABEL Sets the volume label of the filesystem. LABEL can at most be 16 characters long; if it is longer than 16 characters, mkreis- erfs will truncate it. -q | --quiet Sets mkreiserfs to work quietly without producing messages, progress or questions. It is useful, but only for use by end users, if you run mkreiserfs in a script. -j | --journal-device FILE FILE is the name of the block device on which is to be places the filesystem journal. -o | --journal-offset N N is the offset where the journal starts when it is to be on a separate device. Default is 0. N has no effect when the journal is to be on the host device. -s | --journal-size N N is the size of the journal in blocks. When the journal is to be on a separate device, its size defaults to the number of blocks that the device has. When journal is to be on the host device, its size defaults to 8193 and the maximal possible size is 32749 (for blocksize 4k). The minimum size is 513 blocks (whether the journal is on the host or on a separate device). -t | --transaction-max-size N N is the maximum transaction size parameter for the journal. The default, and max possible, value is 1024 blocks. It should be less than half the size of the journal. If specified incorrectly, it will automatically be adjusted. -B | --badblocks file File is the file name of the file that contains the list of blocks to be marked as bad on the filesystem. This list can be created by /sbin/badblocks -b block-size device. -f Forces mkreiserfs to continue even when the device is the whole disk, looks mounted, or is not a block device. If -f is specified more than once, it allows the user to avoid asking for confirmation. -d Sets mkreiserfs to print debugging information during mkreiserfs. -V Prints the version and then exits. AUTHOR
This version of mkreiserfs has been written by Edward Shishkin <edward@namesys.com>. BUGS
Please report bugs to the ReiserFS developers <reiserfs-dev@namesys.com>, providing as much information as possible--your hardware, kernel, patches, settings, all printed messages; check the syslog file for any related information. SEE ALSO
reiserfsck(8), debugreiserfs(8), reiserfstune(8) Reiserfsprogs-3.6.21 January 2009 MKREISERFS(8)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:36 PM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy