Sponsored Content
Full Discussion: SAN vs. Local disk.
Top Forums UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers SAN vs. Local disk. Post 303031279 by bakunin on Monday 25th of February 2019 09:27:32 AM
Old 02-25-2019
Quote:
Originally Posted by ikx
I am in the market looking to purchase a new E950 server and I am trying to decide between using local SSD drives or SSD based SAN. The application that will be running on this server is read-intensive so I am looking for the most optimal configuration to support this application. There are no other servers or applications that will use this SAN (if I decide to go that route.) The deciding factor to me is Performance regardless of the hardware cost (granted I don't want to pay for something I end up not using.) SAN or local SSD (both running RAID 10)? This is really the question I am trying to answer before I pull the trigger and complete this purchase. Any insights from this community is greatly appreciated.
There are a few more points to consider IMHO:

1) disks (regardless which technology) will over time malfunction and need to be replaced. There is some effort involved in such a replacement. SAN systems have usually ways to - more or less - "effortless" replacing disks built in because they usually are used to deal with a lot of disks and the chance that one disk malfunctions rises with the number of disks involved. You might want to do some risk calculation based on how often on average you expect a disk to break (there is usually a "MTBF" - "meantime between failure" number available), how long you expect the change to take and how much a downtime of the expected duration will cost.

2) SANs and local disks do differ in the way they are attached to the system. Local disks may use SCSI or the "M.2" interface. Notice that you cannot have several local (SSD-) disks attached via M.2. SAN, onthe other hand, may use a FC-connection or even several FC-connections in parallel (FC-drivers allow this for redundancy as well as load-balancing). The capacity of such FC-connections may by far exceed the speed of local disks. On the other hand you will need not only a SAN but also a FC-switch (Brocade are the most wide-spread) and the administration ("zoning") will be more complicated.

3) SANs - if set up with this in mind - may add redundancy and thus high-availability to the system. Again, it depends on the system, its purpose, etc.. to calculate properly the risk of it failing for some amount of time. Calculate how much it would set you back to have the system offline for: 1 hour / 1day / 1 week and this will give you an idea how much money spent on preventing these kinds of desasters is worthwhile.

4) SAN systems for themselves are rather expensive. To alleviate this they become cheaper and cheaper (in comparison to local disks) the more you virtualise and the more systems use it. So, a plan to buy a SAN system for a single system only might be on the expensive side but with a expectation of adding other systems using it too the costs may still be reasonable. So you may want to rethink your immediate problem in a more gobal context.

5) Notice that for a system optimised for speed you need an adequate backup solution. For this you also need a disaster scenario plan to estimate what the costs could be and hence how much the prevention may cost. Then you know how fast a recovery needs to be and therefore which technologies you need to employ to get that speed. You can use a SAN also for snapshots (perhaps quickest way of recovering a "point in time"), very fast medium to put an online backup to, only then migrating it to slower media like tapes and similar solutions. You might want to take that also into consideration.

I hope this helps.

bakunin
 

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. AIX

AIX disk less with SAN

Hi All, I have mirrored SAN volume on my B80 rootvg. Can I just remove the mirror and "Remove a P V from a V G" and it will be a diskless AIX? Is that going to boot on SAN rootvg volume? Thanks in advance, itik (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: itik
3 Replies

2. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

disk errors with san snapshot

so we have a solrais 9 system attached to an HP SAN. we are using sssu to do snap clones every hour. the only problem is the we get write errors on the solrais system every time we do a snap. from /var/adm/messages Apr 21 14:37:48 svr001 scsi: WARNING:... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: robsonde
0 Replies

3. AIX

hard disk and san

Hello everyone I got several aix boxes with aix 5.3 I got a ibm san ds4500 My question is How can I do a match between my disks on aix and the san? I try to do a match with the LUN but for example. In my san I got several 1 LUN and on one of my aix box I got this If I type lscfg... (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: lo-lp-kl
4 Replies

4. Solaris

SAN disk failure

hi all, have a solaris 9 OS and a SAN disk which used to work fine is not getting picked up by my machine. can anyone point out things to check in order to troubleshoot this ?? thanks in advance. (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: cesarNZ
3 Replies

5. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

SAN Disk w/o Cluster

Scenario: I've got 2 M5000's connected to a 9985 SAN storage array. I have configured the SAN disks with stmsboot, format and newfs. I can access the same SAN space from both systems. I have created files from both systems on the SAN space. Question: Why can't I see the file created... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: bluescreen
3 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

SAN and Disk I/O ... do we care?

Hi all, My main function is as a DBA. Another person manages the server and the SAN. I just want to know if I should be worried about high disk I/O or is it irrelevant as the I/O "load balancing" will be "taken care" of by the SAN? For example, I have hdisk1-5 and I can see that there are... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: newbie_01
2 Replies

7. Solaris

I/O Error on SAN Disk

Hi, I have a production solaris 10 SPARC system (portal). Yesterday legato/Networker gave an I/O Error on one of the files on its SAN mounted disk. I went to that particular file on the system, did an ls and it showed the file. However, ls -l did not work and it said IO error. ... (6 Replies)
Discussion started by: Mack1982
6 Replies

8. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

Oracle VM / T3 SAN or Local for LDOMS?

I have some T3's we just purchased and we are looking to carve these up into LDOMS's. Just wondering if anyone can give me a quick run down or pro / cons on SAN vs local internal for the LDOM itself. These will external SAN storage for their applications. (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: jlouki01
0 Replies

9. Red Hat

Sharing SAN disk with multiple severs

Hi , I had a requirement to share a san disk between two rhel severs. I am planning to discover the same disk in two rhel nodes and mount it. Is it a feasible solution? and what kind of issues we may encounter mounting same disk in two OS's parallel ? (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: nanduri
2 Replies

10. AIX

SAN Disk Appearing double in AIX

Hello Folks, I have directly connected my IBM Pseries AIX machine to SAN Storage I have a dual port Fibre Channel Adapter Connected both fiber ports to SAN Box IBM DS4500 Controller A & Controller B Using IBM DS storage manager client 10 -- created one logical disk and assigned to a... (18 Replies)
Discussion started by: filosophizer
18 Replies
vxsplitlines(1M)														  vxsplitlines(1M)

NAME
vxsplitlines - show disks with conflicting configuration copies in a cluster SYNOPSIS
vxsplitlines [-g diskgroup] [-c daname] DESCRIPTION
If you import portions of a disk group on different systems, this can lead to conflicting configuration copies on the disks of the disk group. If the configuration information in a disk group is ambiguous, it may not be possible for Veritas Volume Manager to determine which config- uration copy is most up-to-date. (This is usually termed a serial split brain (SSB) condition when it occurs in a cluster.) You cannot import a disk group in this state unless you specify which disk's configuration copy to use. You can use the vxsplitlines command to see which disks in a disk group have conflicting configuration copies, and use this information together with your knowledge of the history of the disk groups' usage to determine which configuration copy is most valid. The output from vxsplitlines displays the vxdg commands that you can run to import the disk group using the available configuration copies. The -o selectcp option of the vxdg import command is used to select the configuration copy to use for the import. OPTIONS
-c daname Display the SSB IDs for each disk that are stored in the configuration copy on the disk specified by its disk access name. Note: Although the SSB IDs for some disks may match, this does not necessarily mean that those disks' configuration copies have recorded all the configuration changes. When viewed from some other configuration copies, the SSB IDs of the same disks may not match. -g diskgroup Specifies the disk group. If a disk group is not specified, the default disk group is used as determined from the rules on the vxdg(1M) manual page. EXAMPLES
Display the disks on each side of the split in the disk group newdg: vxsplitlines -g newdg Display the SSB IDs stored in the configuration copy on disk c2t4d0: vxsplitlines -g newdg -c c2t4d0 NOTES
The vxsplitlines is primarily intended to be used with private disk groups, but it also works with shared disk groups. The version number of the disk group must be 110 or greater. SEE ALSO
vxdg(1M) Veritas Volume Manager Administrator's Guide VxVM 5.0.31.1 24 Mar 2008 vxsplitlines(1M)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:06 AM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy