Sponsored Content
Full Discussion: Unexpected result from awk
Top Forums UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers Unexpected result from awk Post 303015419 by Don Cragun on Wednesday 4th of April 2018 03:23:10 PM
Old 04-04-2018
Quote:
Originally Posted by uniran
Hello,

Giving those commands:

Code:
cat > myfile 
1 
2 
3 
^D 
cat myfile | awk '{ s=s+$1 ; print s}'

The output is:

Code:
1
3
6

It seems like this command iterates each time on a different row so $1 is the first field of each row.. But what caused it to refer to each row ?.
What I mean is, how it knows that for the second iteration for example, $1 should be the first field of the second row rather then the first field of the first row again ?
Because:
  • that is the way awk is described to work,
  • there are no loops in your code to cause an input line in your file to be evaluated more than once,
  • if awk was designed to only process the 1st line in a file (instead of processing each line in a file), it wouldn't be able to process multi-million line input files,
  • et cetera.
What in the description of awk on your system made you think that awk should only process the first line in a file?
 

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. Shell Programming and Scripting

unexpected pipeline result with find -exec

Hi All, I probably miss something fundamental here. I want to rename a bunch of files in subdirectories (that might contain white spaces) with names that are related. I thought following could do the job: find . -name *.sh -exec mv {} $(echo {} | sed -e 's/0/1/g') \; Now to be able to... (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: blued
5 Replies

2. HP-UX

awk to output cmd result

I was wondering if it was possible to tell awk to print the output of a command in the print. .... | awk '{print $0}' I would like it to print the date right before $0, so something like (this doesn't work though) .... | awk '{print date $0}' (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: IMTheNachoMan
4 Replies

3. Shell Programming and Scripting

Unexpected sed result.

I am in the process of writing a script to change the grub password in the grub.conf file. I thought I had it figured out, but am running into an a problem I can't put my finger on. Command I am running when I find that the grub.conf file contains "password --md5". sed... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: viRaven
1 Replies

4. Shell Programming and Scripting

unexpected output within a for loop using awk

Hi all, after hours of playing around with this and scouring the web I decided to ask my fellow UNIX operators as I can't wrap my head around this. First off, I want to parse an input file with tabs (I could pull this off easily with different delimiters) but I was trying to make nicer... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: Keepcase
2 Replies

5. Shell Programming and Scripting

shell script - unexpected result

I hv a file --am executing a script which is giving me unexpected results COntents of file: f1 CMT_AP1_CONT:/opt/sybase/syboc125:150:ASE12_5::Y:UX: CMT_AP1:/opt/sybase/syboc125:150:ASE12_5::Y:UX f1.tmp CMT_AP1_CONT:/opt/sybase/syboc125:150:ASE12_5::Y:UX:... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: rajashekar.y
2 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Weird: unexpected result after piping a sort

Hello, And when you think you know the basics of something, UNIX in this case, something like what I will describe below comes along.... On a Linux system, a "typical" directory with some files. Say 20. I do: > ls | sort > mylisting Now when I: > vi mylisting There is mylisting... (13 Replies)
Discussion started by: stavros
13 Replies

7. Shell Programming and Scripting

AWK Looping. How can I get expected result?

Can Anyone help with looping... awk 'FNR==1{i++} {for(k=1; k<=NF; k++) A=$k} # 3 Dimension Array END{ for(i=1;i<=217;i++) # For loop 2nd File 1st and 2nd column x=0;y=0 ... (18 Replies)
Discussion started by: Akshay Hegde
18 Replies

8. Shell Programming and Scripting

In awk: unexpected EOF while looking for matching `"'

I am trying to get grep with awk command into variable. But facing error. Could someone pls help. $ cat test_file DEPLOYMENT="abc" # com cluster="bcn" $ grep DEPLOYMENT test_file | awk -F "\"" '{ print $2 }' abc $ a=`echo "grep DEPLOYMENT test_file | awk -F \"\\\"\" '{ print $2 }'"` ;... (6 Replies)
Discussion started by: Manasa Pradeep
6 Replies

9. Shell Programming and Scripting

awk problem - erroring out - unexpected token

can anyone help identify where the issue is here? awk 'BEGIN { c="perl -e 'print scalar(localtime("'${EPOCHTIME}'")), "\n"'"; c|getline; close( c ); print $2" "$3" "$4" "$6; }' bash: syntax error near unexpected token `(' can't seem to figure it out. i tried this: awk 'BEGIN {... (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: SkySmart
5 Replies

10. UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers

Duplication | awk | result

Dear forum members, I want the script to count ALA as one (an example in quotes) and return an integer as 1 and not return 5 as an integer as it does now (look bash script). So how can I upgrade my script that it first checks or after finding all instances of ALA checks whether it is the same... (25 Replies)
Discussion started by: Aurimas
25 Replies
A2P(1)							 Perl Programmers Reference Guide						    A2P(1)

NAME
a2p - Awk to Perl translator SYNOPSIS
a2p [options] [filename] DESCRIPTION
A2p takes an awk script specified on the command line (or from standard input) and produces a comparable perl script on the standard output. OPTIONS Options include: -D<number> sets debugging flags. -F<character> tells a2p that this awk script is always invoked with this -F switch. -n<fieldlist> specifies the names of the input fields if input does not have to be split into an array. If you were translating an awk script that processes the password file, you might say: a2p -7 -nlogin.password.uid.gid.gcos.shell.home Any delimiter can be used to separate the field names. -<number> causes a2p to assume that input will always have that many fields. -o tells a2p to use old awk behavior. The only current differences are: o Old awk always has a line loop, even if there are no line actions, whereas new awk does not. o In old awk, sprintf is extremely greedy about its arguments. For example, given the statement print sprintf(some_args), extra_args; old awk considers extra_args to be arguments to "sprintf"; new awk considers them arguments to "print". "Considerations" A2p cannot do as good a job translating as a human would, but it usually does pretty well. There are some areas where you may want to examine the perl script produced and tweak it some. Here are some of them, in no particular order. There is an awk idiom of putting int() around a string expression to force numeric interpretation, even though the argument is always integer anyway. This is generally unneeded in perl, but a2p can't tell if the argument is always going to be integer, so it leaves it in. You may wish to remove it. Perl differentiates numeric comparison from string comparison. Awk has one operator for both that decides at run time which comparison to do. A2p does not try to do a complete job of awk emulation at this point. Instead it guesses which one you want. It's almost always right, but it can be spoofed. All such guesses are marked with the comment ""#???"". You should go through and check them. You might want to run at least once with the -w switch to perl, which will warn you if you use == where you should have used eq. Perl does not attempt to emulate the behavior of awk in which nonexistent array elements spring into existence simply by being referenced. If somehow you are relying on this mechanism to create null entries for a subsequent for...in, they won't be there in perl. If a2p makes a split line that assigns to a list of variables that looks like (Fld1, Fld2, Fld3...) you may want to rerun a2p using the -n option mentioned above. This will let you name the fields throughout the script. If it splits to an array instead, the script is probably referring to the number of fields somewhere. The exit statement in awk doesn't necessarily exit; it goes to the END block if there is one. Awk scripts that do contortions within the END block to bypass the block under such circumstances can be simplified by removing the conditional in the END block and just exiting directly from the perl script. Perl has two kinds of array, numerically-indexed and associative. Perl associative arrays are called "hashes". Awk arrays are usually translated to hashes, but if you happen to know that the index is always going to be numeric you could change the {...} to [...]. Iteration over a hash is done using the keys() function, but iteration over an array is NOT. You might need to modify any loop that iterates over such an array. Awk starts by assuming OFMT has the value %.6g. Perl starts by assuming its equivalent, $#, to have the value %.20g. You'll want to set $# explicitly if you use the default value of OFMT. Near the top of the line loop will be the split operation that is implicit in the awk script. There are times when you can move this down past some conditionals that test the entire record so that the split is not done as often. For aesthetic reasons you may wish to change index variables from being 1-based (awk style) to 0-based (Perl style). Be sure to change all operations the variable is involved in to match. Cute comments that say "# Here is a workaround because awk is dumb" are passed through unmodified. Awk scripts are often embedded in a shell script that pipes stuff into and out of awk. Often the shell script wrapper can be incorporated into the perl script, since perl can start up pipes into and out of itself, and can do other things that awk can't do by itself. Scripts that refer to the special variables RSTART and RLENGTH can often be simplified by referring to the variables $`, $& and $', as long as they are within the scope of the pattern match that sets them. The produced perl script may have subroutines defined to deal with awk's semantics regarding getline and print. Since a2p usually picks correctness over efficiency. it is almost always possible to rewrite such code to be more efficient by discarding the semantic sugar. For efficiency, you may wish to remove the keyword from any return statement that is the last statement executed in a subroutine. A2p catches the most common case, but doesn't analyze embedded blocks for subtler cases. ARGV[0] translates to $ARGV0, but ARGV[n] translates to $ARGV[$n-1]. A loop that tries to iterate over ARGV[0] won't find it. ENVIRONMENT
A2p uses no environment variables. AUTHOR
Larry Wall <larry@wall.org> FILES
SEE ALSO
perl The perl compiler/interpreter s2p sed to perl translator DIAGNOSTICS
BUGS
It would be possible to emulate awk's behavior in selecting string versus numeric operations at run time by inspection of the operands, but it would be gross and inefficient. Besides, a2p almost always guesses right. Storage for the awk syntax tree is currently static, and can run out. perl v5.14.2 2010-12-30 A2P(1)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:38 PM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy