Sponsored Content
Special Forums Cybersecurity Root login in Linux - does it make sense? Post 302728083 by Corona688 on Wednesday 7th of November 2012 10:26:19 AM
Old 11-07-2012
I think you've taken my position a little farther than I've meant it. I do login as root on occasion. I just don't allow root to login externally. That's what sudo's for -- it gives you the same thing in a less blunt, more careful way.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bakunin
Still, apart from private usage there is the corporate usage of Linux systems. Administrating up to several hundreds of (maybe virtualized) Linux systems typically involves carrying out one command on several or all systems in parallel. If i want to know which systems have a certain package/version combination installed I'd issue some rpm-command on all systems, for instance, to find out which systems need a certain update.
If you allow 'sudo su -' you might as well allow sudo to do other things since you have zero effective restrictions anyway. I have one sudo-enabled user that I use for administrative things. So you're left with the enormous hassle of 5 extra keystrokes per command.

Granted, I have made that particular user very difficult to get to via anything but ssh keys. The keys themselves are password protected, too. I login once in the morning, ssh-agent, and have access to my servers throughout the day.

Sometimes I'll push a job into root's cron table if I really need to run an awful lot of root commands.
 

9 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. Answers to Frequently Asked Questions

Lost root password / Can't login as root

We have quite a few threads about this subject. I have collected some of them and arranged them by the OS which is primarily discussed in the thread. That is because the exact procedure depends on the OS involved. What's more, since you often need to interact with the boot process, the... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: Perderabo
0 Replies

2. Linux Benchmarks

Linux Benchmarks Makes No Sense

I created two computers with identical hardware, and run the benchmark programs in both starting at the same exact time. What makes no sense is that the computer that has the lower average index (121) finished the race a good 30 minutes ahead of the computer wich showed the higher avg index... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: philip_38
0 Replies

3. AIX

Can't login root account due to can't find root shell

Hi, yesterday, I changed root's shell in /etc/passwd, cause a mistake then I can not log in root account (can't find correct shell). I attempted to log in single-mode, however, it prompted for single-mode's password then I type root's password but still can not log in. I'm using AIX 5L version 5.2... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: neikel
2 Replies

4. High Performance Computing

Rocks clusters make sense for educational environments

08-18-2008 11:00 AM Cluster computing has played a pivotal role in the way research is conducted in educational environments. Because the amount of available money and hardware varies between university researchers, often it's necessary to find a clustering solution that can work well on a small... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: Linux Bot
0 Replies

5. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

a for loop that doesn't make sense

I've been referring bash info for processes and came across a structure for a process which is defined like typedef struct process { struct process *next; char ** argv . . . }process; What I don't understand is that in the program there's a for loop which goes like this job... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: sdsd
2 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

trying to make sense of rsync output...

I'm running the following rsync command to sync a directory between the 2 servers: rsync -az --delete --stats /some_dir/ server_name:/some_dir I'm getting the following output: Number of files: 655174 Number of files transferred: 14221 Total file size: 1138531979331 bytes Total... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: GKnight
0 Replies

7. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

sar -d output... does not make sense

Can someone explain the correlation between how sar names the disk drives and how the rest of the OS names the disk drives? sar lists my disk drives as sd0, sd1, sd2, etc..... while format lists my disk drives as c1t0d0, c1t1d0, c1t2d0,etc... And also why sar shows 8 disks but format... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: s ladd
2 Replies

8. Red Hat

How to make a Password-Less Login from Windows to Linux using OpenSSH?

I installed the OpenSSH on my Windows Machine. I want to connect to the remote Linux machine without typing password. I followed the bellow instructions but the SSH needs password to establish the connection yet. Open CMD and run: ssh-keygen -t rsa (The public and private keys are generated in... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: manoj.solaris
1 Replies

9. Red Hat

Does it make sense to reduce the total shared memory

We have several dozen Redhat 5, 6 and 7 servers that are running Oracle databases. On some databases we are using automatic memory management, which uses shared memory. On other databases we are use manual memory management, which does not use shared memory. When I see that a server is swapping... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: gandolf989
2 Replies
sudo(8) 						       MAINTENANCE COMMANDS							   sudo(8)

NAME
sudo - execute a command as another user SYNOPSIS
sudo -V | -h | -l | -L | -v | -k | -K | -s | [ -H ] [-P ] [-S ] [ -b ] | [ -p prompt ] [ -c class|- ] [ -a auth_type ] [ -u username|#uid ] command DESCRIPTION
sudo allows a permitted user to execute a command as the superuser or another user, as specified in the sudoers file. The real and effec- tive uid and gid are set to match those of the target user as specified in the passwd file (the group vector is also initialized when the target user is not root). By default, sudo requires that users authenticate themselves with a password (NOTE: by default this is the user's password, not the root password). Once a user has been authenticated, a timestamp is updated and the user may then use sudo without a password for a short period of time (5 minutes unless overridden in sudoers). sudo determines who is an authorized user by consulting the file /etc/sudoers. By giving sudo the -v flag a user can update the time stamp without running a command. The password prompt itself will also time out if the user's password is not entered within 5 minutes (unless overridden via sudoers). If a user who is not listed in the sudoers file tries to run a command via sudo, mail is sent to the proper authorities, as defined at con- figure time or the sudoers file (defaults to root). Note that the mail will not be sent if an unauthorized user tries to run sudo with the -l or -v flags. This allows users to determine for themselves whether or not they are allowed to use sudo. sudo can log both successful and unsuccessful attempts (as well as errors) to syslog(3), a log file, or both. By default sudo will log via syslog(3) but this is changeable at configure time or via the sudoers file. OPTIONS
sudo accepts the following command line options: -V The -V (version) option causes sudo to print the version number and exit. If the invoking user is already root the -V option will print out a list of the defaults sudo was compiled with as well as the machine's local network addresses. -l The -l (list) option will list out the allowed (and forbidden) commands for the user on the current host. -L The -L (list defaults) option will list out the parameters that may be set in a Defaults line along with a short description for each. This option is useful in conjunction with grep(1). -h The -h (help) option causes sudo to print a usage message and exit. -v If given the -v (validate) option, sudo will update the user's timestamp, prompting for the user's password if necessary. This extends the sudo timeout for another 5 minutes (or whatever the timeout is set to in sudoers) but does not run a command. -k The -k (kill) option to sudo invalidates the user's timestamp by setting the time on it to the epoch. The next time sudo is run a password will be required. This option does not require a password and was added to allow a user to revoke sudo permissions from a .logout file. -K The -K (sure kill) option to sudo removes the user's timestamp entirely. Likewise, this option does not require a password. -b The -b (background) option tells sudo to run the given command in the background. Note that if you use the -b option you cannot use shell job control to manipulate the process. -p The -p (prompt) option allows you to override the default password prompt and use a custom one. If the password prompt contains the %u escape, %u will be replaced with the user's login name. Similarly, %h will be replaced with the local hostname. -c The -c (class) option causes sudo to run the specified command with resources limited by the specified login class. The class argument can be either a class name as defined in /etc/login.conf, or a single '-' character. Specifying a class of - indicates that the com- mand should be run restricted by the default login capabilities for the user the command is run as. If the class argument specifies an existing user class, the command must be run as root, or the sudo command must be run from a shell that is already root. This option is only available on systems with BSD login classes where sudo has been configured with the --with-logincap option. -a The -a (authentication type) option causes sudo to use the specified authentication type when validating the user, as allowed by /etc/login.conf. The system administrator may specify a list of sudo-specific authentication methods by adding an "auth-sudo" entry in /etc/login.conf. This option is only available on systems that support BSD authentication where sudo has been configured with the --with-bsdauth option. -u The -u (user) option causes sudo to run the specified command as a user other than root. To specify a uid instead of a username, use #uid. -s The -s (shell) option runs the shell specified by the SHELL environment variable if it is set or the shell as specified in passwd(5). -H The -H (HOME) option sets the HOME environment variable to the homedir of the target user (root by default) as specified in passwd(5). By default, sudo does not modify HOME. -P The -P (preserve group vector) option causes sudo to preserve the user's group vector unaltered. By default, sudo will initialize the group vector to the list of groups the target user is in. The real and effective group IDs, however, are still set to match the target user. -S The -S (stdin) option causes sudo to read the password from standard input instead of the terminal device. -- The -- flag indicates that sudo should stop processing command line arguments. It is most useful in conjunction with the -s flag. RETURN VALUES
Upon successful execution of a program, the return value from sudo will simply be the return value of the program that was executed. Otherwise, sudo quits with an exit value of 1 if there is a configuration/permission problem or if sudo cannot execute the given command. In the latter case the error string is printed to stderr. If sudo cannot stat(2) one or more entries in the user's PATH an error is printed on stderr. (If the directory does not exist or if it is not really a directory, the entry is ignored and no error is printed.) This should not happen under normal circumstances. The most common reason for stat(2) to return "permission denied" is if you are running an automounter and one of the directories in your PATH is on a machine that is currently unreachable. SECURITY NOTES
sudo tries to be safe when executing external commands. Variables that control how dynamic loading and binding is done can be used to sub- vert the program that sudo runs. To combat this the LD_*, _RLD_*, SHLIB_PATH (HP-UX only), and LIBPATH (AIX only) environment variables are removed from the environment passed on to all commands executed. sudo will also remove the IFS, ENV, BASH_ENV, KRB_CONF, KRBCONFDIR, KRBTKFILE, KRB5_CONFIG, LOCALDOMAIN, RES_OPTIONS, HOSTALIASES, NLSPATH, PATH_LOCALE, TERMINFO, TERMINFO_DIRS and TERMPATH variables as they too can pose a threat. If the TERMCAP variable is set and is a pathname, it too is ignored. Additionally, if the LC_* or LANGUAGE vari- ables contain the / or % characters, they are ignored. If sudo has been compiled with SecurID support, the VAR_ACE, USR_ACE and DLC_ACE variables are cleared as well. The list of environment variables that sudo clears is contained in the output of sudo -V when run as root. To prevent command spoofing, sudo checks "." and "" (both denoting current directory) last when searching for a command in the user's PATH (if one or both are in the PATH). Note, however, that the actual PATH environment variable is not modified and is passed unchanged to the program that sudo executes. For security reasons, if your OS supports shared libraries and does not disable user-defined library search paths for setuid programs (most do), you should either use a linker option that disables this behavior or link sudo statically. sudo will check the ownership of its timestamp directory (/var/run/sudo by default) and ignore the directory's contents if it is not owned by root and only writable by root. On systems that allow non-root users to give away files via chown(2), if the timestamp directory is located in a directory writable by anyone (e.g.: /tmp), it is possible for a user to create the timestamp directory before sudo is run. However, because sudo checks the ownership and mode of the directory and its contents, the only damage that can be done is to "hide" files by putting them in the timestamp dir. This is unlikely to happen since once the timestamp dir is owned by root and inaccessible by any other user the user placing files there would be unable to get them back out. To get around this issue you can use a directory that is not world-writable for the timestamps (/var/adm/sudo for instance) or create /var/run/sudo with the appropriate owner (root) and permissions (0700) in the system startup files. sudo will not honor timestamps set far in the future. Timestamps with a date greater than current_time + 2 * TIMEOUT will be ignored and sudo will log and complain. This is done to keep a user from creating his/her own timestamp with a bogus date on systems that allow users to give away files. Please note that sudo will only log the command it explicitly runs. If a user runs a command such as sudo su or sudo sh, subsequent com- mands run from that shell will not be logged, nor will sudo's access control affect them. The same is true for commands that offer shell escapes (including most editors). Because of this, care must be taken when giving users access to commands via sudo to verify that the command does not inadvertantly give the user an effective root shell. EXAMPLES
Note: the following examples assume suitable sudoers(5) entries. To get a file listing of an unreadable directory: % sudo ls /usr/local/protected To list the home directory of user yazza on a machine where the filesystem holding ~yazza is not exported as root: % sudo -u yazza ls ~yazza To edit the index.html file as user www: % sudo -u www vi ~www/htdocs/index.html To shutdown a machine: % sudo shutdown -r +15 "quick reboot" To make a usage listing of the directories in the /home partition. Note that this runs the commands in a sub-shell to make the cd and file redirection work. % sudo sh -c "cd /home ; du -s * | sort -rn > USAGE" ENVIRONMENT
sudo utilizes the following environment variables: PATH Set to a sane value if SECURE_PATH is set SHELL Used to determine shell to run with -s option USER Set to the target user (root unless the -u option is specified) HOME In -s or -H mode (or if sudo was configured with the --enable-shell-sets-home option), set to homedir of the target user. SUDO_PROMPT Used as the default password prompt SUDO_COMMAND Set to the command run by sudo SUDO_USER Set to the login of the user who invoked sudo SUDO_UID Set to the uid of the user who invoked sudo SUDO_GID Set to the gid of the user who invoked sudo SUDO_PS1 If set, PS1 will be set to its value FILES
/etc/sudoers List of who can run what /var/run/sudo Directory containing timestamps AUTHORS
Many people have worked on sudo over the years; this version consists of code written primarily by: Todd Miller Chris Jepeway See the HISTORY file in the sudo distribution or visit http://www.sudo.ws/sudo/history.html for a short history of sudo. BUGS
If you feel you have found a bug in sudo, please submit a bug report at http://www.sudo.ws/sudo/bugs/ DISCLAIMER
Sudo is provided ``AS IS'' and any express or implied warranties, including, but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose are disclaimed. See the LICENSE file distributed with sudo for complete details. CAVEATS
There is no easy way to prevent a user from gaining a root shell if that user has access to commands allowing shell escapes. If users have sudo ALL there is nothing to prevent them from creating their own program that gives them a root shell regardless of any '!' elements in the user specification. Running shell scripts via sudo can expose the same kernel bugs that make setuid shell scripts unsafe on some operating systems (if your OS supports the /dev/fd/ directory, setuid shell scripts are generally safe). SEE ALSO
stat(2), login_cap(3), sudoers(5), passwd(5), visudo(8), grep(1), su(1). 3rd Berkeley Distribution 1.6.6 sudo(8)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:40 PM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy