Sponsored Content
Operating Systems Solaris Difference between sudo & RBAC Post 302275652 by Annihilannic on Sunday 11th of January 2009 08:21:18 PM
Old 01-11-2009
That's too big a question to answer here; if you really want to know all of the differences you should read the documentation for both.

However important considerations are that RBAC is Solaris-only (I think - anyone seen it elsewhere?), whereas sudo is available for most Unix-like platforms.

Personally I find sudo more convenient to maintain because it's all in one file, unlike RBAC. However I think there are some advantages to RBAC as well, such as preventing people from logging in directly as a role, which can be achieved by other means for sudo but is not as straightforward. RBAC is ideally suited for meeting some auditing requirements, such as SOX.
 

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. UNIX Desktop Questions & Answers

what is the difference between Unix & linux, what are the advantages & disadvantages

ehe may i know what are the difference between Unix & Linux, and what are the advantages of having Unix as well as disadvantages of having Unix or if u dun mind i am dumb do pls tell me what are the advantages as well as the disadvantages of having linux as well. thanks (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: cybertechmkteo
1 Replies

2. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

sudo & Sox compliance

Hello, I am trying to convince my boss to stop allowing our users to login as root (superuser). Currently our users login to our unix server with their own account, then as needed, they will do an su and put in the root password. This scares me, for a bunch of reasons. Mainly, one is that we... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: rwallaceisg
1 Replies

3. Linux

Sudo user vs RBAC

Hi all, What the difference between the sudo users & RBAC when the talk of effects after doing the above comes??? any differences between them ,kindly list ?? (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: saurabh84g
1 Replies

4. Solaris

RBAC & Logging

I'm trying to set up RBAC, and I need to know where the logs for RBAC are. I'm using Solaris 10 as my OS. I've been reading a lot of documents online and just can't seem to find where the related logs are. My problem is I need to be able to track a user when they su to a role profile, and... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: bitlord
2 Replies

5. Solaris

sudo for solaris 8 & 9

Dear ALL please can anyone tell me from where can i install sudo for solaris 8 & 9 and how i can install it in the solaris server . (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: thecobra151
1 Replies

6. Solaris

what is the difference between sudo and pbrun?

what is the difference between sudo and pbrun? i have seen people executing pbrun sudo su - what this means?? i know su - will try to switch to root user. what speciality pbrun gives to sudo when it is used along with sudo command? (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: chidori
2 Replies

7. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

What is difference between Power broker utility and sudo command?

Hi I just wanted to know the difference between Using Sudo mechanism over using Power breaker utilities. Are they recommended over sudo? Why ? (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: pinga123
4 Replies

8. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

sudo & chdev

I have an error when using chdev with sudo as follows; sudo chdev -l rmt0 -a block_size=512 chdev: 0514-518 Cannot access the CuDv object class in the device configuration database. I've added chdev in sudoers but still get the error, I guess it's something to do with CuDv... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: gefa
3 Replies

9. Shell Programming and Scripting

Ssh & sudo

when the following command is issued the command prompt is received, how do I get past this? ssh -t usera@hosta sudo su - userb -c id (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: squrcles
4 Replies

10. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Difference between & and nohup &

Hi All, Can anyone please help me understanding what the difference between the below two? 1. script.sh & 2. nohup script.sh & (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: Anupam_Halder
2 Replies
rbac(5) 						Standards, Environments, and Macros						   rbac(5)

NAME
rbac, RBAC - role-based access control DESCRIPTION
The addition of role-based access control (RBAC) to the Solaris operating environment gives developers the opportunity to deliver fine- grained security in new and modified applications. RBAC is an alternative to the all-or-nothing security model of traditional superuser- based systems. With RBAC, an administrator can assign privileged functions to specific user accounts (or special accounts called roles). There are two ways to give applications privileges: 1. Administrators can assign special attributes such as setUID to application binaries (executable files). 2. Administrators can assign special attributes such as setUID to applications using execution profiles. Special attribute assignment along with the theory behind RBAC is discussed in detail in "Role Based Access Control" chapter of the System Administration Guide: Security Services. This chapter describes what authorizations are and how to code for them. Authorizations An authorization is a unique string that represents a user's right to perform some operation or class of operations. Authorization defini- tions are stored in a database called auth_attr(4). For programming authorization checks, only the authorization name is significant. Some typical values in an auth_attr database are shown below. solaris.jobs.:::Cron and At Jobs::help=JobHeader.html solaris.jobs.grant:::Delegate Cron & At Administration::help=JobsGrant.html solaris.jobs.admin:::Manage All Jobs::help=AuthJobsAdmin.html solaris.jobs.user:::Cron & At User::help=JobsUser.html Authorization name strings ending with the grant suffix are special authorizations that give a user the ability to delegate authorizations with the same prefix and functional area to other users. Creating Authorization Checks To check authorizations, use the chkauthattr(3SECDB) library function, which verifies whether or not a user has a given authorization. The synopsis is: int chkauthattr(const char *authname, const char *username); The chkauthattr() function checks the policy.conf(4), user_attr(4), and prof_attr(4) databases in order for a match to the given authoriza- tion. If you are modifying existing code that tests for root UID, you should find the test in the code and replace it with the chkauthattr() function. A typical root UID check is shown in the first code segment below. An authorization check replacing it is shown in the second code segment; it uses the solaris.jobs.admin authorization and a variable called real_login representing the user. Example 1 Standard root check ruid = getuid(); if ((eflag || lflag || rflag) && argc == 1) { if ((pwp = getpwnam(*argv)) == NULL) crabort(INVALIDUSER); if (ruid != 0) { if (pwp->pw_uid != ruid) crabort(NOTROOT); else pp = getuser(ruid); } else pp = *argv++; } else { Example 2 Authorization check ruid = getuid(); if ((pwp = getpwuid(ruid)) == NULL) crabort(INVALIDUSER); strcpy(real_login, pwp->pw_name); if ((eflag || lflag || rflag) && argc == 1) { if ((pwp = getpwnam(*argv)) == NULL) crabort(INVALIDUSER); if (!chkauthattr("solaris.jobs.admin", real_login)) { if (pwp->pw_uid != ruid) crabort(NOTROOT); else pp = getuser(ruid); } else pp = *argv++; } else { For new applications, find an appropriate location for the test and use chkauthattr() as shown above. Typically the authorization check makes an access decision based on the identity of the calling user to determine if a privileged action (for example, a system call) should be taken on behalf of that user. Applications that perform a test to restrict who can perform their security-relevant functionality are generally setuid to root. Programs that were written prior to RBAC and that are only available to the root user may not have such checks. In most cases, the kernel requires an effective user ID of root to override policy enforcement. Therefore, authorization checking is most useful in programs that are setuid to root. For instance, if you want to write a program that allows authorized users to set the system date, the command must be run with an effective user ID of root. Typically, this means that the file modes for the file would be -rwsr-xr-x with root ownership. Use caution, though, when making programs setuid to root. For example, the effective UID should be set to the real UID as early as possible in the program's initialization function. The effective UID can then be set back to root after the authorization check is performed and before the system call is made. On return from the system call, the effective UID should be set back to the real UID again to adhere to the principle of least privilege. Another consideration is that LD_LIBRARY path is ignored for setuid programs (see SECURITY section in ld.so.1(1)) and that shell scripts must be modified to work properly when the effective and real UIDs are different. For example, the -p flag in Bourne shell is required to avoid resetting the effective UID back to the real UID. Using an effective UID of root instead of the real UID requires extra care when writing shell scripts. For example, many shell scripts check to see if the user is root before executing their functionality. With RBAC, these shell scripts may be running with the effective UID of root and with a real UID of a user or role. Thus, the shell script should check euid instead of uid. For example, WHO=`id | cut -f1 -d" "` if [ ! "$WHO" = "uid=0(root)" ] then echo "$PROG: ERROR: you must be super-user to run this script." exit 1 fi should be changed to WHO=`/usr/xpg4/bin/id -n -u` if [ ! "$WHO" = "root" ] then echo "$PROG: ERROR: you are not authorized to run this script." exit 1 fi Authorizations can be explicitly checked in shell scripts by checking the output of the auths(1) utility. For example, for auth in `auths | tr , " "` NOTFOUND do [ "$auth" = "solaris.date" ] && break # authorization found done if [ "$auth" != "solaris.date" ] then echo >&2 "$PROG: ERROR: you are not authorized to set the date" exit 1 fi SEE ALSO
ld.so.1(1), chkauthattr(3SECDB), auth_attr(4), policy.conf(4), prof_attr(4), user_attr(4) System Administration Guide: Security Services SunOS 5.11 15 Jul 2003 rbac(5)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:33 AM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy