Sponsored Content
Full Discussion: sudo question
Special Forums Cybersecurity sudo question Post 302196359 by era on Sunday 18th of May 2008 03:13:47 AM
Old 05-18-2008
Quote:
Originally Posted by divh18
Yes any user can copy bash to /userpath/notbash
But when a non root user issues a sudo notbash,
the user will need to enter root's password to gain root priveleges.
This is not correct. sudo only requires the user's own password.

If I understand correctly, you have configured sudo to allow these users to execute any command they want, and then separately prohibited the shell, in order to prevent them from evading the logging.

The problem is that you cannot enforce your policy if you have a "permit unless prohibited" policy. Only with "prohibit unless permitted" and by explicitly listing the commands the users are allowed to execute as admin can you meaningfully enforce your policy.

These are your options; I don't think you like the answer, but that's how it is. Either explicitly list all the permitted commands, or live with the fact that some user could come up with a workaround to evade the logging. If you trust them to run arbitrary commands, what's to prevent them from installing a remote backdoor if they wanted to? It's "turtles all the way down".
 

9 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

sudo question

how do i go about adding a file to sudo so a user name oracle can run the file??? for some reason my man pages dont have anything for sudo. files sudoers exist in /etc can anyone help this is urgent thank you (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: TRUEST
1 Replies

2. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

SUDO question - please help

Hi, I was wondering if someone can give me some pointers about configuring SUDO. I am trying to configure SUDO to have about 30 users run about 200 scripts as a different user. I understand that I can create an User_Alias but how do I give that User_Alias rights to run all the scripts in a certain... (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: sajjad02
5 Replies

3. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Sudo question

Folks; I have a sudo question: - I have a real user named "greg" and another generic user named "devuser" & application that must be run like start/stop as "devuser" user. Is there a way to: Have user Greg login into the Solaris 10 box as himself then sudo as "devuser" to be able to... (10 Replies)
Discussion started by: Katkota
10 Replies

4. Linux

Sudo question

Hello, I would like to know what should I put on the sudoers file to block a determined group os using just one specific command as root? He can do anything, but not execute program X, how can I do this? Thank you very much. (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: Zarnick
2 Replies

5. Ubuntu

sudo question.

Hello all, Anyone fimilar with su -l command? So when I do su -l <user> any user it doesn't prompt me for password for that user. How I enable sudo to prompt for password whenever su -l command is used. Please help! thanks, -Lalit :D (7 Replies)
Discussion started by: email-lalit
7 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Sudo question

Folks; I have SUDO configured on my SUSE boxes to allow a specific groups to run specific duties so one group has ALL permission & other group has permission to run a few commands only. when i look at the sudoer log, i see people login info only, Is there a way to capture every thing users do... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: Katkota
3 Replies

7. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Question about sudo

Hello all, I have a script (script.sh) that is owned and executed by root. Now I need to give another user (user1) sudo access to execute that script. I edited the /etc/sudoers file, and created the following: # Runas alias specification Runas_Alias RO = root user1 ALL=(RO)... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: designbc
1 Replies

8. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

Sudo question

Hi All I want to grant elevated privs to a user that will be running a script as a background task. It will be launched from an ssh session via an embedded command in its key that just allows that account to run that script. I'm reading up on sudo and notice that - user ALL=(ALL) ALL ... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: steadyonabix
2 Replies

9. AIX

Sudo question

I am running AIX 6.6.5.115 and am experiencing a problem using sudo. I have shell scripts that I created for our HR user and shell scripts that I created for root administrators. I do have a need to embed a sudo command in the user shell script to run one command as root. However the two... (8 Replies)
Discussion started by: RonDeF
8 Replies
VISUDO(8)						       MAINTENANCE COMMANDS							 VISUDO(8)

NAME
visudo - edit the sudoers file SYNOPSIS
visudo [-c] [-q] [-s] [-V] [-f sudoers] DESCRIPTION
visudo edits the sudoers file in a safe fashion, analogous to vipw(8). visudo locks the sudoers file against multiple simultaneous edits, provides basic sanity checks, and checks for parse errors. If the sudoers file is currently being edited you will receive a message to try again later. There is a hard-coded list of one or more editors that visudo will use set at compile-time that may be overridden via the editor sudoers Default variable. This list defaults to "/usr/bin/editor". Normally, visudo does not honor the VISUAL or EDITOR environment variables unless they contain an editor in the aforementioned editors list. However, if visudo is configured with the --with-env-editor option or the env_editor Default variable is set in sudoers, visudo will use any the editor defines by VISUAL or EDITOR. Note that this can be a security hole since it allows the user to execute any program they wish simply by setting VISUAL or EDITOR. visudo parses the sudoers file after the edit and will not save the changes if there is a syntax error. Upon finding an error, visudo will print a message stating the line number(s) where the error occurred and the user will receive the "What now?" prompt. At this point the user may enter "e" to re-edit the sudoers file, "x" to exit without saving the changes, or "Q" to quit and save changes. The "Q" option should be used with extreme care because if visudo believes there to be a parse error, so will sudo and no one will be able to sudo again until the error is fixed. If "e" is typed to edit the sudoers file after a parse error has been detected, the cursor will be placed on the line where the error occurred (if the editor supports this feature). OPTIONS
visudo accepts the following command line options: -c Enable check-only mode. The existing sudoers file will be checked for syntax and a message will be printed to the standard output detailing the status of sudoers. If the syntax check completes successfully, visudo will exit with a value of 0. If a syntax error is encountered, visudo will exit with a value of 1. -f sudoers Specify and alternate sudoers file location. With this option visudo will edit (or check) the sudoers file of your choice, instead of the default, /etc/sudoers. The lock file used is the specified sudoers file with ".tmp" appended to it. -q Enable quiet mode. In this mode details about syntax errors are not printed. This option is only useful when combined with the -c option. -s Enable strict checking of the sudoers file. If an alias is used before it is defined, visudo will consider this a parse error. Note that it is not possible to differentiate between an alias and a host name or user name that consists solely of uppercase letters, digits, and the underscore ('_') character. -V The -V (version) option causes visudo to print its version number and exit. ENVIRONMENT
The following environment variables may be consulted depending on the value of the editor and env_editor sudoers variables: VISUAL Invoked by visudo as the editor to use EDITOR Used by visudo if VISUAL is not set FILES
/etc/sudoers List of who can run what /etc/sudoers.tmp Lock file for visudo DIAGNOSTICS
sudoers file busy, try again later. Someone else is currently editing the sudoers file. /etc/sudoers.tmp: Permission denied You didn't run visudo as root. Can't find you in the passwd database Your userid does not appear in the system passwd file. Warning: {User,Runas,Host,Cmnd}_Alias referenced but not defined Either you are trying to use an undeclare {User,Runas,Host,Cmnd}_Alias or you have a user or host name listed that consists solely of uppercase letters, digits, and the underscore ('_') character. In the latter case, you can ignore the warnings (sudo will not complain). In -s (strict) mode these are errors, not warnings. Warning: unused {User,Runas,Host,Cmnd}_Alias The specified {User,Runas,Host,Cmnd}_Alias was defined but never used. You may wish to comment out or remove the unused alias. In -s (strict) mode this is an error, not a warning. SEE ALSO
vi(1), sudoers(5), sudo(8), vipw(8) AUTHOR
Many people have worked on sudo over the years; this version of visudo was written by: Todd Miller See the HISTORY file in the sudo distribution or visit http://www.sudo.ws/sudo/history.html for more details. CAVEATS
There is no easy way to prevent a user from gaining a root shell if the editor used by visudo allows shell escapes. BUGS
If you feel you have found a bug in visudo, please submit a bug report at http://www.sudo.ws/sudo/bugs/ SUPPORT
Limited free support is available via the sudo-users mailing list, see http://www.sudo.ws/mailman/listinfo/sudo-users to subscribe or search the archives. DISCLAIMER
visudo is provided ``AS IS'' and any express or implied warranties, including, but not limited to, the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose are disclaimed. See the LICENSE file distributed with sudo or http://www.sudo.ws/sudo/license.html for complete details. 1.7.4 July 14, 2010 VISUDO(8)
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:15 AM.
Unix & Linux Forums Content Copyright 1993-2022. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy