Best RAID settings for Debian Server? Help!! (1+0 or 5 or NAS)


 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Operating Systems Linux Debian Best RAID settings for Debian Server? Help!! (1+0 or 5 or NAS)
# 1  
Old 12-30-2011
Best RAID settings for Debian Server? Help!! (1+0 or 5 or NAS)

I am installing a Debian Server on a:

HP Proliant DL380 G4
Dual CPU's 3.20 ghz / 800 mhz / 1MB L2
5120 MB RAM
6 hard disks on HP Smart Array 6i controller (36.4 GB Ultra320 SCSI HD each)


I will be using this server to capture VHS video, encode, compress, cut, edit, make DVD's, rip DVD's, re-encode some more, generally convert large uncompressed files as routine.

I have options:

#1) RAID set to RAID 5 (5 discs) with one spare (6th disk)
I liked this option, because of the spare. My disks are getting older, then are going to brake down, and I really need redundancy. However, I thought the parity processing would really slow down the encoding process. !!!

#2) RAID 1+0
I thought this would be faster, but I can either do 4 disks mirrored (leaves me really two disks size of 36.4GB x2)... Then I would have 1 spare, and one SCSI disk not being used sitting in the server. (some what of a waste, unless I need a quick replacement).

With RAID 5 I have 5 disks @ 36.4GB each and 1 spare
OR
With RAID 1+0 I have 2 disks @ 36.4GB each but I have two spares and mirroring.

I am also considering purchasing a NAS.

Given these scenarios (RAID 5...RAID 1+0....either 5 or 1+0 using a NAS)

What is the best configuration for my needs?
Thank you.
Login or Register to Ask a Question

Previous Thread | Next Thread

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

Revive RAID 0 Array From Buffalo Duo NAS

Thank you in advanced, I had a Buffalo DUO crap out on me that was setup as RAID 0. I dont belive it was the drives but rather the controller in the DUO unit. I bought another external HDD enclosure and was able to fireup the two older DUO drives in it and I think I resembled the RAID... (12 Replies)
Discussion started by: metallica1973
12 Replies

2. Debian

Debian 8 (Jessie): Where are the sound settings?

Dear experts, right now I'm watching a Youtube movie and the sound is on and at maximum in the browser. On my Thinkpad T60 I have also pressed the volume up hardware button as often as possible. Now I'm curious if there are some advanced sound settings, so I can check if the sound level is... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: junior-helper
2 Replies

3. UNIX for Beginners Questions & Answers

Nas server TS-251+

Hello. I have this nas server ts-251+ and I thought about - if it is possible to make a script that can turn on/off for the vpn via crontab. If it's possible ( I dont have any knowledge about scripts myself ), can anyone help me creating the script? Thank you. (6 Replies)
Discussion started by: Kuno
6 Replies

4. Solaris

Reboot required on Server, Just confirm my settings.

Hi Guys, I need to reboot one Server as the newly inserted disk is not getting detected in system , I have also confirmed with Sun Support and finally it was the reboot which was required after doing all troubleshooting stuff. So I have disassembled the mirror and kept working disk's single... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: manalisharmabe
3 Replies

5. UNIX and Linux Applications

Building a NAS server

Hello, I am planning to build a NAS server next week and i was wondering which OS to use. As i see the two most common are FreeNAS and Ubuntu server + samba. What do you think?Do you hava any experience on that?Any other idea? Thanks! (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: @dagio
5 Replies

6. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

Help needed! Raid 5 failure on a Debian System

Hello! I have a 4-disc Raid 5 server running Open Media Vault (Debian). The other day, it disappeared from OMV, which was reporting 3 drives failed. Panic Stations. However, using MDADM I can get info from 3 of the drives which suggests they are functioning ok (info below). The remaining 4th... (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: jonlisty
1 Replies

7. Hardware

3ware RAID server

We have a 3ware RAID server at work, and as the appointed systems administrator (by virtue of being the one with the most knowledge) I've taken on the job of maintaining it. I've installed smartmontools on it to keep an eye on the drives and run scans every day, and looking at the data from the... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: Krendoshazin
0 Replies

8. Debian

backup debian-nas

hello i want to backup my debian running nas (only the debian part) i wanna do this over ssh is this possible and how to do this thx ---------- Post updated at 07:02 AM ---------- Previous update was at 06:57 AM ---------- the thing is i f this is possible i wanne have te back up of... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: joosted
2 Replies

9. Hardware

Raid 0 on database server

Hi guys. if we want to use SSD drives on a database server, can we use RAID 0 configuration because of their reliability? (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: majid.merkava
3 Replies

10. Filesystems, Disks and Memory

Adding RAID to server

Hi, I have a server that I am adding a RAID that we purchased to. The server works fine. It is running Fedora 7 and is a Dell Precision 690. When the RAID is attached, it boots up and says the following: Controller Bus #00, Device#1F, Function#02: 00 Ports No device found AHCI BIOS not... (0 Replies)
Discussion started by: user23
0 Replies
Login or Register to Ask a Question
HPSA(4) 						     Linux Programmer's Manual							   HPSA(4)

NAME
hpsa - HP Smart Array SCSI driver SYNOPSIS
modprobe hpsa [ hpsa_allow_any=1 ] DESCRIPTION
hpsa is a SCSI driver for HP Smart Array RAID controllers. Options hpsa_allow_any=1: This option allows the driver to attempt to operate on any HP Smart Array hardware RAID controller, even if it is not explicitly known to the driver. This allows newer hardware to work with older drivers. Typically this is used to allow installation of operating systems from media that predates the RAID controller, though it may also be used to enable hpsa to drive older controllers that would normally be handled by the cciss(4) driver. These older boards have not been tested and are not supported with hpsa, and cciss(4) should still be used for these. Supported hardware The hpsa driver supports the following Smart Array boards: Smart Array P700M Smart Array P212 Smart Array P410 Smart Array P410i Smart Array P411 Smart Array P812 Smart Array P712m Smart Array P711m StorageWorks P1210m Since Linux 4.14, the following Smart Array boards are also supported: Smart Array 5300 Smart Array 5312 Smart Array 532 Smart Array 5i Smart Array 6400 Smart Array 6400 EM Smart Array 641 Smart Array 642 Smart Array 6i Smart Array E200 Smart Array E200i Smart Array E200i Smart Array E200i Smart Array E200i Smart Array E500 Smart Array P400 Smart Array P400i Smart Array P600 Smart Array P700m Smart Array P800 Configuration details To configure HP Smart Array controllers, use the HP Array Configuration Utility (either hpacuxe(8) or hpacucli(8)) or the Offline ROM-based Configuration Utility (ORCA) run from the Smart Array's option ROM at boot time. FILES
Device nodes Logical drives are accessed via the SCSI disk driver (sd(4)), tape drives via the SCSI tape driver (st(4)), and the RAID controller via the SCSI generic driver (sg(4)), with device nodes named /dev/sd*, /dev/st*, and /dev/sg*, respectively. HPSA-specific host attribute files in /sys /sys/class/scsi_host/host*/rescan This is a write-only attribute. Writing to this attribute will cause the driver to scan for new, changed, or removed devices (e.g., hot-plugged tape drives, or newly configured or deleted logical drives, etc.) and notify the SCSI midlayer of any changes detected. Normally a rescan is triggered automatically by HP's Array Configuration Utility (either the GUI or the command-line variety); thus, for logical drive changes, the user should not normally have to use this attribute. This attribute may be useful when hot plugging devices like tape drives, or entire storage boxes containing preconfigured logical drives. /sys/class/scsi_host/host*/firmware_revision This attribute contains the firmware version of the Smart Array. For example: # cd /sys/class/scsi_host/host4 # cat firmware_revision 7.14 HPSA-specific disk attribute files in /sys /sys/class/scsi_disk/c:b:t:l/device/unique_id This attribute contains a 32 hex-digit unique ID for each logical drive. For example: # cd /sys/class/scsi_disk/4:0:0:0/device # cat unique_id 600508B1001044395355323037570F77 /sys/class/scsi_disk/c:b:t:l/device/raid_level This attribute contains the RAID level of each logical drive. For example: # cd /sys/class/scsi_disk/4:0:0:0/device # cat raid_level RAID 0 /sys/class/scsi_disk/c:b:t:l/device/lunid This attribute contains the 16 hex-digit (8 byte) LUN ID by which a logical drive or physical device can be addressed. c:b:t:l are the controller, bus, target, and lun of the device. For example: # cd /sys/class/scsi_disk/4:0:0:0/device # cat lunid 0x0000004000000000 Supported ioctl() operations For compatibility with applications written for the cciss(4) driver, many, but not all of the ioctls supported by the cciss(4) driver are also supported by the hpsa driver. The data structures used by these ioctls are described in the Linux kernel source file include/linux/cciss_ioctl.h. CCISS_DEREGDISK, CCISS_REGNEWDISK, CCISS_REGNEWD These three ioctls all do exactly the same thing, which is to cause the driver to rescan for new devices. This does exactly the same thing as writing to the hpsa-specific host "rescan" attribute. CCISS_GETPCIINFO Returns PCI domain, bus, device and function and "board ID" (PCI subsystem ID). CCISS_GETDRIVVER Returns driver version in three bytes encoded as: (major_version << 16) | (minor_version << 8) | (subminor_version) CCISS_PASSTHRU, CCISS_BIG_PASSTHRU Allows "BMIC" and "CISS" commands to be passed through to the Smart Array. These are used extensively by the HP Array Configuration Utility, SNMP storage agents, and so on. See cciss_vol_status at <http://cciss.sf.net> for some examples. SEE ALSO
cciss(4), sd(4), st(4), cciss_vol_status(8), hpacucli(8), hpacuxe(8), <http://cciss.sf.net>, and Documentation/scsi/hpsa.txt and Documentation/ABI/testing/sysfs-bus-pci-devices-cciss in the Linux kernel source tree COLOPHON
This page is part of release 4.15 of the Linux man-pages project. A description of the project, information about reporting bugs, and the latest version of this page, can be found at https://www.kernel.org/doc/man-pages/. Linux 2017-09-15 HPSA(4)