[post moved]

Yes, i did... let me state my problem in more detail
Inputs:
I have one input CSV file
And, i have stored no. of comma each line should in a variable.
e.g.

$ cat cmt.csv
this, is a ,comma ,count test1
,,this, is a ,comma ,count test2
this, is a ,comma ,count test3
Thisisaline,withoutspace,test1
Thisisaline,withoutspace,test2
this, line is ,lacking comma test1
this, line is ,lacking comma test2

and,
export row_comma=3

Now, requirement is:
if, in a line, no. of commas not equal to $row_comma then write this line into cmt.bad, and remove this line from cmt.csv.
To achieve this, i hv written something as below. which is working fine if there are NO spaces in input cmt.csv... but whenever there is a space its a mess.

#$FEED_DIR/$feed_nm=cmt.csv
for k in `cat $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm`
do
echo $k > $FEED_DIR/tmp.lst
line_comma_cnt=`awk ' BEGIN { count=0; }
{ for (i=1;i<=length($0);i++)
{
if(substr($0,i,1)=="," ) {count++;}
}
}
END {print count} ' $FEED_DIR/tmp.lst`
echo "New count: $line_comma_cnt"

#rm -f $EXCEPTION_DIR/${feed_nm}_insufficient_data.bad
rm -f $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.tmp

#echo line comma count $line_comma_cnt and row comma count is $row_comma

if [[ $line_comma_cnt != $row_comma ]]
then
# echo "count mismatch, prepare separate files"
# cp $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.orig
#echo line is $k
# grep `cat $FEED_DIR/tmp.lst ` >> $FEED_DIR/lack.txt
grep $k $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm >> $EXCEPTION_DIR/${feed_nm}_insufficient_data.bad
# grep -v $k $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm > $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.tmp
# mv $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.tmp $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm
fi
done

#echo intial insuff count is `wc -l $EXCEPTION_DIR/${feed_nm}_insufficient_data.bad`

for d in `cat $EXCEPTION_DIR/${feed_nm}_insufficient_data.bad `
do
#echo "in test area `wc -l $EXCEPTION_DIR/${feed_nm}_insufficient_data.bad` "
grep -v $d $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm > $FEED_DIR/${feed_nm}.tmp
#echo after temp `wc -l $FEED_DIR/${feed_nm}.tmp `

mv $FEED_DIR/${feed_nm}.tmp $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm
# cp $FEED_DIR/${feed_nm}.tmp $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm
done

i will really appreciate, if someone help me out to get the desired result in optimal way.

Thanks
Dipali

You can try something like this (backup your data first, use gawk, nawk or /usr/xpg4/bin/awk on Solaris):

awk 'BEGIN {
  FS = ","; te = "tmp"; be = "bad"
  ffn = fn = ARGV[2]; sub(/[^.]*$/,"", fn)
  }
{ 
  print > (fn (NF != nf + 1 ? be : te)) 
  }
END {
  if (system("mv " fn te OFS ffn)) {
    print "error moving", fn te, "to", ffn | "cat >&2"
    exit 1
    }
  }' nf="$row_comma" cmt.csv

Thanks for your reply....
But this block is giving errorpossibly the simple one... but i m not good in awk programming), so pls suggest what wrong i m doing

awk 'BEGIN {
> FS = ","; te = "tmp"; be = "bad"
> ffn = fn = ARGV[2]; sub(/[^.]*$/,"", fn)
> }
> {
> print > (fn (NF != nf + 1 ? be : te))
> }
> END {
> if (system("mv " fn te OFS ffn)) {
> print "error moving", fn te, "to", ffn | "cat >&2"
> exit 1
> }
> }' nf="$row_comma" cmt.csv
mv: cannot stat `cmt.tmp': No such file or directory
error moving cmt.tmp to cmt.csv

It seems there are no valid records in cmt.csv ...
Try this one:

awk 'BEGIN {
  FS = ","; te = "tmp"; be = "bad"
  ffn = fn = ARGV[2]; sub(/[^.]*$/,"", fn)
  }
{ 
  print > (fn (NF != nf + 1 ? be : te)) 
  }
END {
  if (system("[ -f " fn te " ] && mv " fn te OFS ffn)) {
    print "error moving", fn te, "to", ffn, \
    "or no valid records found" | "cat >&2"
    exit 1
    }
  }' nf="$row_comma" cmt.csv

Another approach:

awk -F"," '
NF != n+1 {print > "cmt.bad"; next}
1' n=$row_comma cmt.csv > cmt.new 

mv cmt.new cmt.csv

Thanks a lot Radoulov & Franklin52 for such a compact solutions, And 3 liner approach is wonderful !!!
well, both approches working fine for me. Now i need little more enhancement in it that when i merged this piece of code into my shell script where i need to create bad file name dynamically e.g.

awk -F"," '
NF != n+1 {print > "$feed_nm.bad"; next}
1' n=$row_comma $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm > $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.new

cp $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.new $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm

So, can you please guide me here as well.

Thanks
Dipali

Try something like this:

feed_nm.bad="cmt.bad"

awk -F"," '
NF != n+1 {print > bad; next}
1' n=$row_comma bad="$feed_nm.bad" $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm > $FEED_DIR/$feed_nm.new