Undestanding LANG setting in /etc/environment


 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Operating Systems AIX Undestanding LANG setting in /etc/environment
# 1  
Old 03-09-2013
Undestanding LANG setting in /etc/environment

Hi All,

We had issue with a application which reports process counts in log, application used to log process counts as Integer data type (1500).

One fine morning we started seeing process counts in application log as Decimal (1,500).

Our UNIX admin did investigate and figured-out that change in LANG setting in /etc/environment has caused application to log process counts in log as Decimal instead of Integer and was told that LANG was changed to en_US from C.

Here I am trying to understand why this should cause Integer values in log got changed to Decimal data type.

I would appreciate if anybody can help me to understand.

Thanks
Aaron
# 2  
Old 03-10-2013
Different countries & cultures often use different conventions to format numbers, to write the date and time or to delimit words and phrases.

C locale is a rather neutral locale which has same settings across different systems.

But in en_US locale, the number format changes and is represented with a thousand separator.

See below how gawk output changes when I specify different locales:
Code:
$ LC_ALL=C gawk 'BEGIN{printf "%'\''d\n", 1234}'
1234
$ LC_ALL=en_US gawk 'BEGIN{printf "%'\''d\n", 1234}'
1,234

I hope this helps.
# 3  
Old 03-10-2013
What happens if you change LANG back to C, assuming it was changed? Does that fix the problem? Is the timestamp consistent with the date of that fine morning when the problem started?

1500 and 1,500 both seem "integer" to me, so I don't understand why you say "decimal" to describe the problem. Aren't those two numbers the same, with the only difference whether a thousands separator is used?
# 4  
Old 03-10-2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaron Boyce
Our UNIX admin did investigate and figured-out that change in LANG setting in /etc/environment has caused application to log process counts in log as Decimal instead of Integer and was told that LANG was changed to en_US from C.
There are many AIX facilities which are represented differently in various cultures. Language (of the man pages, of command status output, ...), how numbers are represented, keyboard layout and many other things. All this is controlled by some environment variables of which "LANG" is one (and probably the most important). Issue the "set" command and you will see "LANG", but probably also "LC_MESSAGES" and a few others.

It is possible to control this "language environment" for every process separately, simply by setting the language variable to a different value upon process start, like this:

Code:
# (export LANG=<some_value> ; command)

Now for the role of "/etc/environment": as you have issued "set" you sure have noticed there are a lot of variables assigned. Most of these variables are not set explicitly by you, but get assigned default values. These system-wide default values are stored in "/etc/environment". Have a look at it, it is a simple text file with declarations in the form

Code:
# comment line
variable=value

Every time you log in your environment initially gets filled with these defaults. After this your own changes to the environment are being applied and you can change and override any of these defaults. You certainly have a special user for the program you are talking about. If you depend on the LANG variable to have a certain value it is a wise idea to explicitly set it in your startup scripts ("~/.profile") even if it is to the same value as the default. Even if the default changes your environment will remain as it is. I suggest to add a line

Code:
LANG=C ; export LANG

to your profile or shell startup script. The "export" keyword will make sure every process started from this process inherits this setting. Btw.: the same is true for other environment settings one of your programs depend on. Set these explicitly, even if it is to the same value the variable already has. When the default changes you avoid possible problems.

I hope this helps.

bakunin
# 5  
Old 03-10-2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by bakunin
There are many AIX facilities which are represented differently in various cultures. Language (of the man pages, of command status output, ...), how numbers are represented, keyboard layout and many other things. All this is controlled by some environment variables of which "LANG" is one (and probably the most important). Issue the "set" command and you will see "LANG", but probably also "LC_MESSAGES" and a few others.

It is possible to control this "language environment" for every process separately, simply by setting the language variable to a different value upon process start, like this:

Code:
# (export LANG=<some_value> ; command)

Now for the role of "/etc/environment": as you have issued "set" you sure have noticed there are a lot of variables assigned. Most of these variables are not set explicitly by you, but get assigned default values. These system-wide default values are stored in "/etc/environment". Have a look at it, it is a simple text file with declarations in the form

Code:
# comment line
variable=value

Every time you log in your environment initially gets filled with these defaults. After this your own changes to the environment are being applied and you can change and override any of these defaults. You certainly have a special user for the program you are talking about. If you depend on the LANG variable to have a certain value it is a wise idea to explicitly set it in your startup scripts ("~/.profile") even if it is to the same value as the default. Even if the default changes your environment will remain as it is. I suggest to add a line

Code:
LANG=C ; export LANG

to your profile or shell startup script. The "export" keyword will make sure every process started from this process inherits this setting. Btw.: the same is true for other environment settings one of your programs depend on. Set these explicitly, even if it is to the same value the variable already has. When the default changes you avoid possible problems.

I hope this helps.

bakunin
Setting LANG=C will do what Aaron Boyce wants only if neither LC_ALL nor LC_NUMERIC is set in the environment. LC_NUMERIC will override LANG for purposes of determining the radix character used and the formatting of numeric output. LC_ALL will override both LANG and LC_NUMERIC.

If LC_NUMERIC is effectively set to a value that sets non-null thousands separators or that uses comma as the radix character, you need to take extra precautions when working with CSV files that contain numeric strings that represent non-integral values, or integral values greater than 999 or less than -999.
# 6  
Old 03-10-2013
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Cragun
Setting LANG=C will do what Aaron Boyce wants only if neither LC_ALL nor LC_NUMERIC is set in the environment. LC_NUMERIC will override LANG for purposes of determining the radix character used and the formatting of numeric output. LC_ALL will override both LANG and LC_NUMERIC.

If LC_NUMERIC is effectively set to a value that sets non-null thousands separators or that uses comma as the radix character, you need to take extra precautions when working with CSV files that contain numeric strings that represent non-integral values, or integral values greater than 999 or less than -999.
You are right, Don, as always. In his entry posting Aaron stated that his SysAdmin has traced back the problem to the changed LANG-entry in /etc/environment, so i took it that none of the applicable LC_-variables are defined in his case, because these would have overridden the old as well as the new setting.

Still, its a good idea to explain the interdependence of LANG and LC_ALL the other LC_-variables.

I hope this helps.

bakunin
Login or Register to Ask a Question

Previous Thread | Next Thread

10 More Discussions You Might Find Interesting

1. Solaris

/etc/default/init LANG Setting Not Working

Hey guys, I'm setting up a new server(Fujitsu M10-4 / Solaris 10 1/13) to move our app/DB and I'm having trouble figuring out why my LANG setting is not taking effect. I'm trying to set LANG=C in the /etc/default/init file which should make it the default system wide from what I gather. However... (7 Replies)
Discussion started by: kaledragule
7 Replies

2. Red Hat

Setting up LAMP environment

I wish to setup LAMP environment. Amongst, I have successfully installed Linux 6.1. I am looking fwd to install - Apace Web Server, My Sql Database & PHP environment. Say if I look for MySql, could see downloadable available in rpm format. But this must be copied over to Linux machine. As... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: videsh77
2 Replies

3. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Setting up environment variables

Hi all, This is my first post here. I need to set up a few environment variables with a shell script. Some are hard-coded, but some should come from other commands or as input from the user. How do I do that? For example, I need to export a variable as such: export DISPLAY=127.0.0.1:8.0 ... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: exchequer598
2 Replies

4. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Setting Environment Variables

#!/bin/bash if ; then ASS1_DATA_DIR=./ echo $ASS1_DATA_DIR export ASS1_DATA_DIR echo "data dir" fi if ; then ASS1_OUTPUT_DIR=./ export ASS1_OUTPUT_DIR fi I want to create a new environment variable ASS1_DATA_DIR and ASS1_OUTPUT_DIR in bash and set them to the current... (4 Replies)
Discussion started by: bigubosu
4 Replies

5. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Need help with setting up environment variables

hi all, I would appreciate if some one could explain me the difference between setting up the variables as shown below HOME=${HOME:-"/home/user1"} HOME=/home/user1 (1 Reply)
Discussion started by: SSSB
1 Replies

6. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Setting up your environment

Hi I am new to Solaris and was just given my id and need to setup my environment, what do i need to do to run certain commands without putting in the complete path. How do I create my .profile, I do not see under my login? Any help would be greatly appreciated. (5 Replies)
Discussion started by: sa_ken
5 Replies

7. Programming

Setting Environment variable..!

Hi, I already have one CPP program which invokes the C program.And the C program contains whole function definitions..!This is a working program..I have to enable the logs in both CPP as well as in the C program ..!So I am reading the enviornmental variable log path from the CPP and doing the... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: Kattoor
2 Replies

8. UNIX for Advanced & Expert Users

sudo environment setting?

Hi, first post. As the nick suggests I'm a Unix noob, but I'm doing everything I can to learn fast...job requirement. These forums have been a huge help so far. I have a server running HP-UX 11.23b with Apache/2.0.59 HP-UX_Apache-based_Web_Server. Apache is not installed in the default... (3 Replies)
Discussion started by: nixnoob
3 Replies

9. UNIX for Dummies Questions & Answers

Setting the $LANG info needed

Hello (Very New to UNIX -Solaris 10) I'm trying to set the LANG variable to C but not sure if it's getting set, need some help on this. Currently I have it set to en_GB.UTF-8 I need to set it to C for an install. but when I run set LANG=C and then run echo $LANG its still set to... (2 Replies)
Discussion started by: deedaz
2 Replies

10. Shell Programming and Scripting

Setting up Environment Variables

Hi all, I am trying to set up some variables in a shell script. The variables contain values of various paths needed to run a java module. The problem is the variables dont seem to be setting at all. here is what i am trying to do : JAR_HOME=/home/was5/bdcms/scheduledjobs/lib export... (6 Replies)
Discussion started by: rpandey
6 Replies
Login or Register to Ask a Question